Re: [mb-style] RFC: Add "Has News Coverage At" AR

2010-02-27 Thread Brian Schweitzer
The same had occurred to me, though I'm not 100% decided if such a potentally large list of URLs would be a good or bad thing; I could see it almost becoming some sort of fodder for a future "news about artists I'm subscribed to" rss feed. The origin of this AR was in last week's dev meeting, wher

Re: [mb-style] RFC: Add "Has News Coverage At" AR

2010-02-27 Thread Chad Wilson
I think this needs to be properly clarified as to its intention. People will start adding links to individual articles about artists or releases which /surely/ cannot be the goal of this proposal? If that were it happen it seems to me that it will create an absolute mess of links of dubious mer

Re: [mb-style] RFC: Add "Has News Coverage At" AR

2010-02-27 Thread Brian Schweitzer
Sorry, that should read Sunday, 2010-03-07. On Sun, Feb 28, 2010 at 2:18 AM, Brian Schweitzer < brian.brianschweit...@gmail.com> wrote: > Note: I am sending this RFC on ruoak's behalf; in case of disagreement > between he and I on this proposal, he's the Idea Champion here, not me - no > need fo

Re: [mb-style] RFC: Extend the Has Lyrics At AR to artists

2010-02-27 Thread Brian Schweitzer
Sorry, that should read Sunday, 2010-03-07. On Sun, Feb 28, 2010 at 2:12 AM, Brian Schweitzer < brian.brianschweit...@gmail.com> wrote: > Currently, the Has Lyrics At AR allows only release-URL and track-URL links > to lyrics.wikia.com. This RFC would extend the AR to also allow > artist-URL lin

[mb-style] RFC: Add "Has News Coverage At" AR

2010-02-27 Thread Brian Schweitzer
Note: I am sending this RFC on ruoak's behalf; in case of disagreement between he and I on this proposal, he's the Idea Champion here, not me - no need for him to use Style Elder to override Style Leader. :D This would add a new AR, linking artists and releases to press pages where news coverage

[mb-style] RFC: Extend the Has Lyrics At AR to artists

2010-02-27 Thread Brian Schweitzer
Currently, the Has Lyrics At AR allows only release-URL and track-URL links to lyrics.wikia.com. This RFC would extend the AR to also allow artist-URL links, such as linking http://lyrics.wikia.com/Tori_Amos to the Tori Amos listing. This RFC is RFC-90, and has a proposal page at http://wiki.musi

Re: [mb-style] RFC (4th try): add attribute 'translated' to LyricistRelationshipType

2010-02-27 Thread Brian Schweitzer
On Sat, Feb 27, 2010 at 8:39 AM, Jan van Thiel wrote: > Hi, > > This is a fourth RFC, rephrased compared to the third RFC. On the JIRA > bug tracker this RFC is located at [4]. > > -- > > I'd like to see attribute 'translated' added to the Lyricist > Relationship Type[1]. > > The phrase f

Re: [mb-style] RFC: Live Bootleg Style, Live Track Style

2010-02-27 Thread Brian Schweitzer
I've run into a few of those, even on silver bootlegs.( See http://musicbrainz.org/release/8c519124-b55a-4e9f-9a00-cac80dadd7d6.html for example). Splitting it in the listing, no matter the source, seems wrong to me; if it was distributed as a single track, then that's the release - any splitting

Re: [mb-style] RFC (4th try): add attribute 'translated' to LyricistRelationshipType

2010-02-27 Thread Jan van Thiel
Sorry, [4] should be http://bugs.musicbrainz.org/ticket/4424 as it has been moved back to Trac. On 27 February 2010 14:39, Jan van Thiel wrote: > Hi, > > This is a fourth RFC, rephrased compared to the third RFC. On the JIRA > bug tracker this RFC is located at [4]. > > -- > > I'd like to

[mb-style] RFC (4th try): add attribute 'translated' to LyricistRelationshipType

2010-02-27 Thread Jan van Thiel
Hi, This is a fourth RFC, rephrased compared to the third RFC. On the JIRA bug tracker this RFC is located at [4]. -- I'd like to see attribute 'translated' added to the Lyricist Relationship Type[1]. The phrase for this attribute could read "This attribute describes if the lyrics are a

Re: [mb-style] RFC: Live Bootleg Style, Live Track Style

2010-02-27 Thread jacobbrett
I have a question related to LBS: What is to be done with live recordings that are one audio file? I keep getting recordings from a local taper's blog, but they're always a single MP3 file. Should I split it myself (or CUE sheet) and call that the official tracklist/track times? -- View this mes