No debate still ongoing, this proposal is now at RFV. Without veto, the proposal will pass on 2010-04-06.
Thanks, Brian On Sun, Mar 28, 2010 at 6:20 PM, Brian Schweitzer < brian.brianschweit...@gmail.com> wrote: > There's been no comments in two days; so this can't get 'stuck' in the > 'ongoing debate' status w/o an RFV date, I'm going to go ahead and re-RFC, > with the new 'tour' attribute and guidance language. Further debate is > encouraged if anyone sees problems, but barring that, this will go to RFV on > 2010-04-04. > > Thanks, > Brian > > > > I've tweaked the AR more, to add a tour attribute like that, and a few > other minor things. > >> >> >> http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/User:BrianSchweitzer/Live_Performance_Relationship_Type_Proposal >> >> I've added explicit guidance that TV, radio, and internet-streamed >> performances are 'live', since these sometimes end up categorized as >> 'other', not 'live'. >> >> I've explicitly excluded studio-recorded or demo tracks from the release >> at all - imho, the 20% that's not from the one live performance still should >> be from *some* live performance. >> >> I've added a tour compilation attribute. The forward link phrase is easy, >> but I'm not sure what the backward link phrase should be if that attribute >> is used. I kept the same 80% guideance for the AR w/o that attribute, but I >> brought back almost the original 1:1 guidance for if the attribute *is* >> used. >> >> If it's a true tour compilation of a live performance, then I feel it >> really should be 1:1 with the release, esp in the studio -> live direction. >> For the live -> studio direction, I know I've seen tour compilations which >> also included a couple of songs from the singles, or added a cover that was >> played during the tour. So I've tried to make the language there >> restrictive, but still allow for those types of situations. >> > >
_______________________________________________ Musicbrainz-style mailing list Musicbrainz-style@lists.musicbrainz.org http://lists.musicbrainz.org/mailman/listinfo/musicbrainz-style
