Sorry for coming in so late, but maybe we should go back to RFC and rethink
the whole thing: I understand and share Ross Tyler's concerns about making
a guideline singloing out just one word. Right now what seems to be the
consensus about the *general* guideline use whatever link-term is written
Den 14-12-2013 13:24, SwissChris skrev:
Sorry for coming in so late, but maybe we should go back to RFC and
rethink the whole thing: I understand and share Ross Tyler's concerns
about making a guideline [...]
This RFC is not making (or even changing!) a guideline, it's rewording
an already
Pretty much exactly what Freso said, with my style leader hat on. For
further improvements please send a second RFC in a couple days :)
On 14 Dec 2013 15:05, Frederik Freso S. Olesen freso...@gmail.com
wrote:
Den 14-12-2013 13:24, SwissChris skrev:
Sorry for coming in so late, but maybe we
Also, I would think that our guidance would include the reason(s) why
featuring is so special that it needs to be normalized while all other
words are not.
Without this rationale, I am afraid, this guidance is just dogma.
The problem here is that we are dealing with a genre specific
Expected expiration date: December 15
Bug tracker: http://tickets.musicbrainz.org/browse/STYLE-270
Wiki proposal:
http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/User:Tularion/Featured_artists_clarification
Forum discussion: forums.musicbrainz.org/viewtopic.php?pid=23765
Clarifies which creditings should be
Thanks for championing this cause.
Improvement here is long overdue.
As I mentioned in RFC, I believe the best improvement would be to scrap
this guidance altogether.
I understand, however, that that is beyond what you are trying to do -
which is to keep the accepted guidance but make it
On Fri, Dec 13, 2013 at 6:29 PM, Ross Tyler rossety...@gmail.com wrote:
However, if our rationale for this normalization is to make such MB
taggers happy, why is it being limited to just English?
It seems to me the same rationale should apply equally to all languages.
Shouldn't we want to
On 12/13/2013 08:38 AM, Nicolás Tamargo de Eguren wrote:
On Fri, Dec 13, 2013 at 6:29 PM, Ross Tyler rossety...@gmail.com
mailto:rossety...@gmail.com wrote:
However, if our rationale for this normalization is to make such
MB taggers happy, why is it being limited to just English?
