Re: [mythtv-users] Broadcast flag (tell me why myth users should care technically?)

2005-05-09 Thread Endaf Jones
Wendy Seltzer wrote: The BF requires "compliant devices" not to transmit unencrypted high-def streams over any user-accessible bus. Instead, they must implement the flag in a manner "robust against user modification" -- so if they'd seen the flag, they could only allow down-rez'd signals over

Re: [mythtv-users] Broadcast flag (tell me why myth users should care technically?)

2005-05-08 Thread Wendy Seltzer
At 3:02 PM -0600 5/8/05, Endaf Jones wrote: Thank you Joe for your comments. Very simply: If the Broadcast flag becomes law, all ATSC recording devices with Linux drivers will no longer be sold. Your hardware selection will GO AWAY. That's why it is important, even to Canadians. However (and I'm

Re: [mythtv-users] Broadcast flag (tell me why myth users should care technically?)

2005-05-08 Thread Brad Benson
On 5/8/05, Endaf Jones <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Thank you Joe for your comments. > > >Very simply: If the Broadcast flag becomes law, all ATSC recording > >devices with Linux drivers will no longer be sold. Your hardware > >selection will GO AWAY. That's why it is important, even to Canadian

Re: [mythtv-users] Broadcast flag (tell me why myth users should care technically?)

2005-05-08 Thread Endaf Jones
Thank you Joe for your comments. Very simply: If the Broadcast flag becomes law, all ATSC recording devices with Linux drivers will no longer be sold. Your hardware selection will GO AWAY. That's why it is important, even to Canadians. However (and I'm not trying to be argumentative, but rather s

Re: [mythtv-users] Broadcast flag (tell me why myth users should care technically?)

2005-05-08 Thread Joe Barnhart
--- Endaf Jones <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Why does the flag matter to us myth users ? (in terms of hardware > selection) Very simply: If the Broadcast flag becomes law, all ATSC recording devices with Linux drivers will no longer be sold. Your hardware selection will GO AWAY. That's why it i

Re: [mythtv-users] Broadcast flag (tell me why myth users should care technically?)

2005-05-07 Thread Endaf Jones
Ian Trider wrote: Why does the flag matter to us myth users ? (in terms of hardware selection) Assuming this is true, isn't it a simple case of modifying myth source code in order to enforce/ignore the flag? (regardless of ATSC card flag implementation). My understanding of the issue i

Re: [mythtv-users] Broadcast flag (tell me why myth users should care technically?)

2005-05-07 Thread Ian Trider
> Why does the flag matter to us myth users ? (in terms of hardware selection) > Assuming this is true, isn't it a simple case of modifying myth source > code in order to enforce/ignore the flag? (regardless of ATSC card flag > implementation). My understanding of the issue is that yes, this is m

[mythtv-users] Broadcast flag (tell me why myth users should care technically?)

2005-05-07 Thread Endaf Jones
Why does the flag matter to us myth users ? (in terms of hardware selection) Doesn't the ATSC card/driver just pass the data stream down (unaltered) and myth just records that stream to a file? Isn't the real magic in enforcing the flag in the software that decodes or plays the file once it's b