Re: East Coast outage?

2003-08-16 Thread Iljitsch van Beijnum
On zaterdag, aug 16, 2003, at 05:38 Europe/Amsterdam, Eric Germann wrote: And the nukes tripping off was probably more an artifact of frequency instability on the grid than a problem with the nukes themselves. Maybe a stupid question... But what if the huge distribution systems used DC and the

Re: East Coast outage?

2003-08-16 Thread Chris Adams
Once upon a time, Iljitsch van Beijnum [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: Maybe a stupid question... But what if the huge distribution systems used DC and the whole thing was only converted to AC close to the users in small installations? This would get rid of the frequency problems. Basic physics.

Re: East Coast outage?

2003-08-16 Thread Brandon Butterworth
But what if the huge distribution systems used DC the UK - France interconnect is DC http://www.nationalgrid.com/uk/activities/other/mn_interconnectors_france.html though a relatively short distance it does provide isolation brandon

Re: East Coast outage?

2003-08-16 Thread Iljitsch van Beijnum
On zaterdag, aug 16, 2003, at 10:48 Europe/Amsterdam, Chris Adams wrote: But what if the huge distribution systems used DC and the whole thing was only converted to AC close to the users in small installations? This would get rid of the frequency problems. Basic physics. To run DC at the power

Re: East Coast outage?

2003-08-16 Thread Geo.
My guess is when it shakes out, the failure will be traced to a rather large unit or interconnect tripping offline. It will be traced back to a huge branch from a huge tree that fell and took down a couple of transmission lines which then melted the road in a fairly expensive neighborhood in

Re: East Coast outage?

2003-08-16 Thread Andrew Odlyzko
Let me add yet another $0.02 worth, weighing in on the side defending the electric power industry. Let's take a very high level economic point of view. Should oodles of money be spent improving the power generation and transmission grid? Suppose that the current system were judged likely to

Re: East Coast outage?

2003-08-16 Thread David Lesher
Speaking on Deep Background, the Press Secretary whispered: Maybe a stupid question... But what if the huge distribution systems used DC and the whole thing was only converted to AC close to the users in small installations? This would get rid of the frequency problems. True, and

Re: East Coast outage?

2003-08-16 Thread Steven M. Bellovin
In message [EMAIL PROTECTED], Scott A Crosby writes: I don't know, but at least reading this IEEE Spectrum article: http://www.ece.umr.edu/courses/f02/ee207/spectrum/Grid/ implies that long distance transmission is full of strange and nonlinear effects such as 'reactive power', voltage support,

AOL modem banks rely on local power

2003-08-16 Thread Sean Donelan
AOL's modem banks, which relay data over phone lines in New York City and Detroit and other affected regions, had gone down after local electricity grids blinked off Thursday evening. AOL spokesman Nicholas Graham. Most of the power at our modem banks rely on local power supplies.

Re: East Coast outage?

2003-08-16 Thread Jay Hennigan
On Sat, 16 Aug 2003, Chris Adams wrote: Basic physics. To run DC at the power levels required, the wire would have to be over 100 feet in diameter IIRC. Look up the Edison vs. Tesla power arguments for all kinds of information on AC vs. DC. Edison and Tesla's arguments took place long

NERC: power outage update August 16

2003-08-16 Thread Sean Donelan
The bulk electric transmission system in the United States and Canada has been restored and is operating reliably. Many of the generating units that tripped off line during the outage have returned to service and additional generating units are expected to return to service over the weekend.

Re: East Coast outage?

2003-08-16 Thread David Lesher
Speaking on Deep Background, the Press Secretary whispered: AC still makes sense for distribution, but HV DC transmission lines are becoming the norm. Think about some very large SCRs and associated parts to convert to AC for distribution. For several reasons You must size the

Re: East Coast outage?

2003-08-16 Thread David Lesher
I just thought of a better analogy. The goal of almost any aeronautical engineer is to build a plane that has good positive stability; you let go the stick and it reverts to stable, level flight. The reality of the power system more resembles the V22 Osprey, or the Shuttle 'flying' on final

But few companies say that they are as fully prepared as Equinix

2003-08-16 Thread Sean Donelan
ATT reported 97 out of 100 generators worked in their network. MCI had one generator fail due to a burned out part. Two carrier hotels had problems with backup generators. For backup generators that is an excellent performance. The Department of Energy study found typically fewer backup

Re: But few companies say that they are as fully prepared as Equinix

2003-08-16 Thread ren
As an Equinix-Newark customer I can say the periodic informational update efforts were appreciated as well. Mission critical services never noticed the blip in their facilities. -ren At 03:43 PM 8/16/2003 -0400, Sean Donelan wrote: ATT reported 97 out of 100 generators worked in their

Re: East Coast outage?

2003-08-16 Thread Michael Painter
http://www.hydro.mb.ca/our_facilities/ts_nelson.shtml - Original Message - From: Chris Adams [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Friday, August 15, 2003 10:48 PM Subject: Re: East Coast outage? Once upon a time, Iljitsch van Beijnum [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: Maybe a

Re: East Coast outage?

2003-08-16 Thread Stephen Sprunk
Thus spake Petri Helenius [EMAIL PROTECTED] subsidize) local power generation via renewable energy sources (e.g. solar, wind, hydro) it would go a long way towards solving this problem. Rubbish. If in order to make it viable such energy needs to be subsidized then it is not

Re: East Coast outage?

2003-08-16 Thread Chris Lewis
David Lesher wrote: True, and it's done. There are two very large DC lines in use: The Pacific Intertie, from Washington State down to Califunny A line from the Great Frozen North down to Minnesota. IIUC, after the ice storm's enormous damage Hydro Quebec replaced their interconnects with

Re: East Coast outage?

2003-08-16 Thread Chris Lewis
Chris Adams wrote: Basic physics. To run DC at the power levels required, the wire would have to be over 100 feet in diameter IIRC. Look up the Edison vs. Tesla power arguments for all kinds of information on AC vs. DC. This was under the assumption that the transmission line was at the same

Re: East Coast outage?

2003-08-16 Thread hackerwacker
On Saturday 16 August 2003 03:58 pm, Having folded space, the Third Stage Guild Navigator said: http://www.hydro.mb.ca/our_facilities/ts_nelson.shtml - Original Message - From: Chris Adams [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Friday, August 15, 2003 10:48 PM Subject: Re:

Re: East Coast outage?

2003-08-16 Thread Chris Adams
Once upon a time, Chris Lewis [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: Chris Adams wrote: Basic physics. To run DC at the power levels required, the wire would have to be over 100 feet in diameter IIRC. Look up the Edison vs. Tesla power arguments for all kinds of information on AC vs. DC. This was under