RE: Abstract of proposed Internet Draft for Best Current Practice (please comment)

2003-03-10 Thread E.B. Dreger
DJR> Date: Mon, 10 Mar 2003 22:17:56 +0700 DJR> From: Dr. Jeffrey Race DJR> Please read the details in the text. It is all spelt out DJR> there. I'm glad someone has spelt out how we can find our way out of the spam maize. Hopefully the details are explained with sufficient granularity, and w

RE: Abstract of proposed Internet Draft for Best Current Practice (please comment)

2003-03-10 Thread Cutler, James R
lto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Friday, March 07, 2003 9:06 AM To: Dr. Jeffrey Race Cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Abstract of proposed Internet Draft for Best Current Practice (please comment) quote: > Well-managed, ethical members of the internet industry already conduct > thei

RE: Abstract of proposed Internet Draft for Best Current Practice (please comment)

2003-03-07 Thread cproctor
I actually see several problems with this: 1.) Near as I can tell, Emergent Structures are observed phenomena. They are not tools for social engineering. 2.) You suggest pushing this at "appropriate bodies." Near as I know... there is no such animal. 3.) You say in the header that you're look

Re: Abstract of proposed Internet Draft for Best Current Practice(please comment)

2003-03-07 Thread Andy Dills
On Fri, 7 Mar 2003, Dr. Jeffrey Race wrote: > Whether it is implemented is not my business. I am the doctor > diagnosing the illness and prescribing the scientifically validated > cure, and warning the patient of the quack remedies on the market. > My job is done now (almost, I just have to refo

Re: Abstract of proposed Internet Draft for Best Current Practice (please comment)

2003-03-07 Thread Peter Galbavy
McBurnett, Jim wrote: > To be blunt: > It seems that your opinion is: If a company wants to dump trash in > my email account > and they are able to find an ISP who is so blindly just taking a > payment and cares less > about what who they provide service to, so be it, I don't care. I did not eve

Re: Abstract of proposed Internet Draft for Best Current Practice (please comment)

2003-03-07 Thread Dr. Jeffrey Race
On Fri, 7 Mar 2003 14:05:31 -, Peter Galbavy wrote: >quote: >> Well-managed, ethical members of the internet industry already conduct >> their businesses, successfully and profitably, according to the >> principles specified in the Practice. The proposed Practice simply >> aims to raise the en

Re: Abstract of proposed Internet Draft for Best Current Practice (please comment)

2003-03-07 Thread Peter Galbavy
quote: > Well-managed, ethical members of the internet industry already conduct > their businesses, successfully and profitably, according to the > principles specified in the Practice. The proposed Practice simply > aims to raise the entire industry to the level of today's best > players. I obj

Re: [Re: Abstract of proposed Internet Draft for Best Current Practice (please comment)]

2003-03-06 Thread Dr. Jeffrey Race
Thank you Josh, please see inline comments which let me clarify points On Thu, 06 Mar 2003 13:17:35 -0500, Joshua Smith wrote: >is there a forthcoming section on criterium for demonstrating reformation >by the sp and/or 'offending' user? The criterion is stated: no more complaints > >the pro

Re: Abstract of proposed Internet Draft for Best Current Practice (please comment)

2003-03-06 Thread Dr. Jeffrey Race
Thank you Andy for making my points so clearly. See inline comments On Thu, 6 Mar 2003 12:30:11 -0500 (EST), Andy Dills wrote: >Some comments, after reading the draft: >>Under 2.1, Form of Practice, where you finally talk about what it is >you're propsing: >>"The withdrawal of IR (use of blockli

Re: Abstract of proposed Internet Draft for Best Current Practice(please comment)

2003-03-06 Thread Andy Dills
Some comments, after reading the draft: Under 2.1, Form of Practice, where you finally talk about what it is you're propsing: "The withdrawal of IR (use of blocklists, cancellation of routing, withdrawal of IP addresses and domain names) may in its early months of adoption split the Internet in