Re: Determine difference between 2 BGP feeds

2006-04-18 Thread Tuc
> More than likely, one provider is feeding too many routes -- some that I > have run across tend to feed more specific internal routes (read: > redistributing IGP into BGP) to customer BGP sessions. > > The two I've run across, after I yelled, they fixed. > I quickly took a look for a

RE: Determine difference between 2 BGP feeds

2006-04-18 Thread Alex Rubenstein
"Tuc" Ellentuch at T-B-O-H Sent: Tuesday, April 18, 2006 4:13 PM To: nanog@merit.edu Subject: Determine difference between 2 BGP feeds Hi, We receive a BGP feed from different providers on two different routers. While one seems to be a reasonable amount of feeds after reviewing

Re: Determine difference between 2 BGP feeds

2006-04-18 Thread Bill Nash
On Tue, 18 Apr 2006, David Andersen wrote: Much of what Bill described below is already present using Nick Feamster's bgptools release: http://nms.lcs.mit.edu/software/bgp/bgptools/ Start with zebra / quagga / etc., which do a great job of dumping tables and updates. Then use bgptools to

Re: Determine difference between 2 BGP feeds

2006-04-18 Thread Tuc
Hi, Thanks for all the replies! I've consolidated them here hoping to save some noise > From: Bill Nash <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> >Were I faced with this reporting equirement on an on-going basis, I'd >suggest establishing a read-only BGP peer with both devices and comparing >directly.

RE: Determine difference between 2 BGP feeds

2006-04-18 Thread Lasher, Donn
On Apr 18, Scott Tuc Ellentuch at T-B-O-H <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Is there a utility that I can use that will pull the routes off each > router (Foundry preferred), and then compare them as best it can to > see why there is such a difference? I have one, but it's cisco-specific: >

Re: Determine difference between 2 BGP feeds

2006-04-18 Thread David Andersen
Much of what Bill described below is already present using Nick Feamster's bgptools release: http://nms.lcs.mit.edu/software/bgp/ bgptools/ Start with zebra / quagga / etc., which do a great job of dumping tables and updates. Then use bgptools to take the MRT-formatted dumps that Zebra sp

Re: Determine difference between 2 BGP feeds

2006-04-18 Thread Bill Nash
Were I faced with this reporting equirement on an on-going basis, I'd suggest establishing a read-only BGP peer with both devices and comparing directly. I've got a perl BGP peering daemon that feeds and maintains a mirror of the BGP routing table into SQL, applying updates and withdrawals

Re: Determine difference between 2 BGP feeds

2006-04-18 Thread Richard A Steenbergen
On Tue, Apr 18, 2006 at 04:28:40PM -0400, Scott Tuc Ellentuch at T-B-O-H wrote: > > > > > On Tue, 18 Apr 2006, Scott Tuc Ellentuch at T-B-O-H wrote: > > > > > Is there a utility that I can use that will pull the > > > routes off each router (Foundry preferred), and then compare > > > them as

Re: Determine difference between 2 BGP feeds

2006-04-18 Thread Marco d'Itri
On Apr 18, Scott Tuc Ellentuch at T-B-O-H <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Is there a utility that I can use that will pull the > routes off each router (Foundry preferred), and then compare > them as best it can to see why there is such a difference? I have one, but it's cisco-specific: htt

Re: Determine difference between 2 BGP feeds

2006-04-18 Thread John Kristoff
On Tue, 18 Apr 2006 16:13:12 -0400 (EDT) Scott "Tuc" Ellentuch at T-B-O-H <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Is there a utility that I can use that will pull the > routes off each router (Foundry preferred), and then compare > them as best it can to see why there is such a difference? I don't

Re: Determine difference between 2 BGP feeds

2006-04-18 Thread Warren Kumari
Systems Administrator -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Scott "Tuc" Ellentuch at T-B-O-H Sent: Tuesday, April 18, 2006 4:13 PM To: nanog@merit.edu Subject: Determine difference between 2 BGP feeds Hi, We receive a BGP

Re: Determine difference between 2 BGP feeds

2006-04-18 Thread Tuc
> > On Tue, 18 Apr 2006, Scott Tuc Ellentuch at T-B-O-H wrote: > > > Is there a utility that I can use that will pull the > > routes off each router (Foundry preferred), and then compare > > them as best it can to see why there is such a difference? > > I can understand a handful of routes o

RE: Determine difference between 2 BGP feeds

2006-04-18 Thread Mike Walter
t;Tuc" Ellentuch at T-B-O-H Sent: Tuesday, April 18, 2006 4:13 PM To: nanog@merit.edu Subject: Determine difference between 2 BGP feeds Hi, We receive a BGP feed from different providers on two different routers. While one seems to be a reasonable amount of feeds after reviewin

Re: Determine difference between 2 BGP feeds

2006-04-18 Thread Jon Lewis
On Tue, 18 Apr 2006, Scott Tuc Ellentuch at T-B-O-H wrote: Is there a utility that I can use that will pull the routes off each router (Foundry preferred), and then compare them as best it can to see why there is such a difference? I can understand a handful of routes over what CIDR say

Determine difference between 2 BGP feeds

2006-04-18 Thread Tuc
Hi, We receive a BGP feed from different providers on two different routers. While one seems to be a reasonable amount of feeds after reviewing the CIDR report, the other is anywhere from 3K to 10K more routes. Is there a utility that I can use that will pull the routes off eac