Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-27 Thread Andre Oppermann
Nik Hug wrote: From: "Andre Oppermann" From running a Colo in a place with ridiculus high electricity engery costs (Zurich/Switzerland) I can tell you that the energy consuption of routers/telco (70%) and servers (30%) changes changes significantly throughout the day. It pretty much follows the tr

Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-27 Thread Nik Hug
From: "Andre Oppermann" > From running a Colo in a place with ridiculus high electricity engery > costs (Zurich/Switzerland) I can tell you that the energy consuption > of routers/telco (70%) and servers (30%) changes changes significantly > throughout the day. It pretty much follows the traffic

Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-27 Thread Andre Oppermann
Steven M. Bellovin wrote: In message <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Alex Rubenst ein writes: Hello, I've done quite a bit of studyin power usage and such in datacenters over the last year or so. I'm looking for information on energy consumption vs percent utilization. In other words if your datacenter con

Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-26 Thread David Lesher
Speaking on Deep Background, the Press Secretary whispered: > [KWH meter] > Instead of doing all this, just buy a Kill-A-Watt meter for about $30, and > get an instant reading of Watts, Amps, VAs, power factor, and KWH. Interesting. I've not seen anything near that cheap. The spec sheet is ra

Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-26 Thread Krzysztof Adamski
On Tue, 26 Oct 2004, David Lesher wrote: > > Speaking on Deep Background, the Press Secretary whispered: > > > > > > You should be able to pick up simple current / wattage meter from local > > hardware store for $20 or so. That will tell you that on a modern > > dual-CPU machine the power consump

Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-26 Thread David Lesher
Speaking on Deep Background, the Press Secretary whispered: > > > You should be able to pick up simple current / wattage meter from local > hardware store for $20 or so. That will tell you that on a modern > dual-CPU machine the power consumption at idle CPU is about 60% of peak. > The rest i

Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-26 Thread Alex Rubenstein
I doubt that very much, or we wouldn't have variable speed fans. I've monitored CPU temperature when doing compilations; it goes up significantly. That suggests that the CPU is drawing more power at such times. I don't doubt what you are saying. However, I did say, "in the grand scheme of thin

RE: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-26 Thread Hannigan, Martin
[mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Behalf Of > james edwards > Sent: Tuesday, October 26, 2004 4:18 PM > To: Alex Rubenstein > Cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > Subject: Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization? > > > > > Thats an insane statement. > > > > Are you saying,

Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-26 Thread Petri Helenius
Alex Rubenstein wrote: I'm looking for information on energy consumption vs percent utilization. In other words if your datacenter consumes 720 MWh per month, yet on average your servers are 98% underutilized, you are wasting a lot of energy (a hot topic these days). Does anyone here have any

Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-26 Thread james edwards
> Thats an insane statement. > > Are you saying, "You are only wasting money on things if you aren't > profitable" ? > > /action shakes head. No, I am not but my statement did sure sound like that was what I was saying. I do think it is apples or oranges comparing CPU % to total power used and co

Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-26 Thread Steven M. Bellovin
In message <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Alex Rubenst ein writes: > > >Hello, > >I've done quite a bit of studyin power usage and such in datacenters over >the last year or so. > >> I'm looking for information on energy consumption vs percent utilization. In > >> other words if your datacenter consumes 7

Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-26 Thread Alex Rubenstein
On Tue, 26 Oct 2004, Erik Haagsman wrote: It's more or less the truth though. I think the comment was outside of the scope of the original discussion. It seemed to me that: It is only waste is the P & L statement is showing no profit. inferred that any business practice is OK, as long as your ar

Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-26 Thread Erik Haagsman
It's more or less the truth though. Only on rare occasions, such as the cluster/fail-over scenario given, can you actually supply less power to certain machines, and power use largely unrelated to their actual utilisation. Keep an eye on your UPS load during peak hours and you'll see the load risi

Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-26 Thread Jack Bates
Erik Haagsman wrote: Which means you have to make sure the revenue generated by those 98% underutilized servers covers your powerbill and other expenses, preferrably leaving some headroom for a healthy profit margin. As long as that's the case there's no real waste of energy, the services peop

Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-26 Thread Alex Rubenstein
Thats an insane statement. Are you saying, "You are only wasting money on things if you aren't profitable" ? /action shakes head. On Tue, 26 Oct 2004, james edwards wrote: Sorry, this is somewhat OT. I'm looking for information on energy consumption vs percent utilization. In other words if yo

Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-26 Thread Alex Rubenstein
Hello, I've done quite a bit of studyin power usage and such in datacenters over the last year or so. I'm looking for information on energy consumption vs percent utilization. In other words if your datacenter consumes 720 MWh per month, yet on average your servers are 98% underutilized, you a

Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-26 Thread james edwards
> > Sorry, this is somewhat OT. > > I'm looking for information on energy consumption vs percent utilization. > In other words if your datacenter consumes 720 MWh per month, yet on > average your servers are 98% underutilized, you are wasting a lot of > energy (a hot topic these days). Does anyone

RE: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-26 Thread Hannigan, Martin
October 26, 2004 2:09 PM > To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > Subject: Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization? > > > > On Tue, Oct 26, 2004 at 01:52:51PM -0400, Gregory (Grisha) > Trubetskoy wrote: > > > Sorry, this is somewhat OT. > > Also Sorry, but I think the

Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-26 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
On Tue, 26 Oct 2004 13:52:51 EDT, "Gregory (Grisha) Trubetskoy" said: > average your servers are 98% underutilized, you are wasting a lot of Remember in your analysis to include premature hardware failure due to too many power cycles... A server can *easily* "on average" be running at only 20-3

Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-26 Thread Deepak Jain
Actually I think nobody does calculate "real" utilization, as there are a lot of soft factors to be taken into account. Electrical usage for a datacenter is pretty consistent throughout a month, even as measured by a sum of days. The utilization of the systems inside of it are almost anything

Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-26 Thread Erik Haagsman
On Tue, 2004-10-26 at 19:52, Gregory (Grisha) Trubetskoy wrote: > In other words if your datacenter consumes 720 MWh per month, yet on > average your servers are 98% underutilized, you are wasting a lot of > energy (a hot topic these days). Which means you have to make sure the revenue generat

Re: Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-26 Thread Nils Ketelsen
On Tue, Oct 26, 2004 at 01:52:51PM -0400, Gregory (Grisha) Trubetskoy wrote: > Sorry, this is somewhat OT. Also Sorry, but I think the question itself is completely flawed. > I'm looking for information on energy consumption vs percent utilization. > In other words if your datacenter consumes

Energy consumption vs % utilization?

2004-10-26 Thread Gregory (Grisha) Trubetskoy
Sorry, this is somewhat OT. I'm looking for information on energy consumption vs percent utilization. In other words if your datacenter consumes 720 MWh per month, yet on average your servers are 98% underutilized, you are wasting a lot of energy (a hot topic these days). Does anyone here have