Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-19 Thread JC Dill
Chris Adams wrote: Once upon a time, Patrick W. Gilmore <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> said: Depends on what you call "caching". Does honoring a TTL qualify as caching? What other kind of DNS caching is there? There's an article on /. today about providers (apparently there are quite a lot of them

Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-18 Thread Randy Bush
> It would be very interesting in seeing the difference in DNS traffic for a > domain if it sets TTL to let's say 600 seconds or 86400 seconds. This > could perhaps be used as a metric in trying to figure out the impact of > capping the TTL? Anyone know if anyone did this on a large domain and

Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-18 Thread Matthew Sullivan
Mikael Abrahamsson wrote: On Mon, 18 Apr 2005, Jason Frisvold wrote: Is it possible to "prevent" poisoning attacks? Is it beneficial, or even possible, to prevent TTL's from being an excessively high value? It would be very interesting in seeing the difference in DNS traffic for a domain if it

Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-18 Thread Tony Rall
On Monday, 2005-04-18 at 22:08 ZE2, "Peter & Karin Dambier" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Preventing poisoning attacks: > > I guess most attacks are against windows workstations. I'm not sure what you mean by this. Cache poisoning applies to machines that are doing caching. It can affect any

Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-18 Thread Peter & Karin Dambier
> Is it possible to "prevent" poisoning attacks? Is it beneficial, or > even possible, to prevent TTL's from being an excessively high value? > > -- > Jason 'XenoPhage' Frisvold > [EMAIL PROTECTED] > Preventing poisoning attacks: I guess most attacks are against windows workstations. 1) Hid

Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-18 Thread Jason Frisvold
On 4/18/05, Mikael Abrahamsson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > It would be very interesting in seeing the difference in DNS traffic for a > domain if it sets TTL to let's say 600 seconds or 86400 seconds. This > could perhaps be used as a metric in trying to figure out the impact of > capping the TTL

Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-18 Thread Florian Weimer
* Mikael Abrahamsson: > If one had to repeate the cache poisoning every 10 minutes I guess life > would be much harder than if you had to do it once every day? Not necessarily, because every cache refresh is a new attack opportunity. 8-)

Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-18 Thread Florian Weimer
* Jason Frisvold: > I think this is more of a question of who to trust. Caching, in > general, isn't a bad thing provided that TTL's are adhered to. If the > poisoning attack were to inject a huge TTL value, then that would > compromise that cache. (Note, I am no expert on dns poisoning, so I'

Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-18 Thread Rachael Treu Gomes
On Mon, Apr 18, 2005 at 03:05:55PM -0400, Jason Frisvold said something to the effect of: > > On 4/18/05, Daniel Golding <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > > > > Aside from individual OS behavior, doesn't this seem like very bad advice? > > I think this is more of a question of who to trust. C

Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-18 Thread Mikael Abrahamsson
On Mon, 18 Apr 2005, Jason Frisvold wrote: Is it possible to "prevent" poisoning attacks? Is it beneficial, or even possible, to prevent TTL's from being an excessively high value? It would be very interesting in seeing the difference in DNS traffic for a domain if it sets TTL to let's say 600 s

Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-18 Thread Jason Frisvold
On 4/18/05, Daniel Golding <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > Aside from individual OS behavior, doesn't this seem like very bad advice? I think this is more of a question of who to trust. Caching, in general, isn't a bad thing provided that TTL's are adhered to. If the poisoning attack were to

Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-18 Thread Daniel Golding
Aside from individual OS behavior, doesn't this seem like very bad advice? What sort of DNS cache poisoning attack could possibly work against a workstation that has a caching resolver but no DNS server? If a hacker really wished to do a name resolution attack against workstations, wouldn't they

Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-18 Thread Patrick W. Gilmore
On Apr 18, 2005, at 2:02 PM, Chris Adams wrote: Once upon a time, Patrick W. Gilmore <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> said: Most desktop OSes do not re-query for the name again. Don't confuse apps and OSes. If I run "lynx", it does a DNS lookup for each connect (even when it is the same hostname). I wasn't.

Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-18 Thread Eric Louie
- Original Message - From: "Chris Adams" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Sent: Monday, April 18, 2005 10:35 AM Subject: Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations That's what most Unix/Linux/*BSD boxes do unless they are running a local ca

Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-18 Thread Chris Adams
Once upon a time, Patrick W. Gilmore <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> said: > Most desktop OSes do not re-query for the name again. Don't confuse apps and OSes. If I run "lynx", it does a DNS lookup for each connect (even when it is the same hostname). -- Chris Adams <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Systems and Network

Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-18 Thread Paul G
- Original Message - From: "Erik Amundson" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Sent: Monday, April 18, 2005 1:45 PM Subject: RE: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations > Windows definitely caches DNS entries...but as far as I've seen, it do

Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-18 Thread Patrick W. Gilmore
On Apr 18, 2005, at 1:35 PM, Chris Adams wrote: Can you imagine what would happen if every time anyone ever looked up any hostname they sent out a DNS query? That's what most Unix/Linux/*BSD boxes do unless they are running a local caching name service of some time (BIND, nscd, etc.). I wasn't act

RE: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-18 Thread Erik Amundson
message in any form, printed or electronic. -Original Message- From: Chris Adams [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Monday, April 18, 2005 12:35 PM To: nanog@merit.edu Subject: Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations Once upon a time, Patrick W. Gilmore <[EM

Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-18 Thread Chris Adams
Once upon a time, Patrick W. Gilmore <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> said: > Depends on what you call "caching". Does honoring a TTL qualify as > caching? What other kind of DNS caching is there? > Can you imagine what would happen if every time anyone ever looked up > any hostname they sent out a DNS

Re: Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-18 Thread Patrick W. Gilmore
On Apr 18, 2005, at 11:45 AM, Jay R. Ashworth wrote: Here we go again... http://techrepublic.com.com/5100-10595-5657417.html?tag=nl.e044 My initial reaction is "why?" My followup reaction is "Well, most workstations don't cache anyway, do they?" Depends on what you call "caching". Does honoring a

Jonathan Yarden @ TechRepublic: Disable DNS caching on workstations

2005-04-18 Thread Jay R. Ashworth
Here we go again... http://techrepublic.com.com/5100-10595-5657417.html?tag=nl.e044 My initial reaction is "why?" My followup reaction is "Well, most workstations don't cache anyway, do they?" Cheers, -- jra -- Jay R. Ashworth[EMAIL PROTECTED] D