Re: SMTP Port Blocking: Success or Failure?

2005-02-28 Thread Jason Nealis
We put our blocks in place some time ago, Mainly on the Cable Modem side. We found our userbase was very prone to becoming zombie agents for spam. We did enhance our static i.p product by allowing statics to have port 25 open, this averted any real business class customers to continue to

RE: SMTP Port Blocking: Success or Failure?

2005-02-28 Thread Paul Ryan
PROTECTED] Subject: Re: SMTP Port Blocking: Success or Failure? What about rate limiting SMTP traffic rather than blocking it? That could allow legitimate use for most private customers, while preventing bulk traffic. Comcast has been doing something like that, looking for spikes of SMTP

Re: SMTP Port Blocking: Success or Failure?

2005-02-27 Thread Ketil Froyn
Quoting Claydon, Tom [EMAIL PROTECTED]: We are considering filtering outbound SMTP traffic from our ISP customers, except from our own mail servers, to help reduce the amount of spam originating from our network. How successful/unsucessful has implementing outbound SMTP filtering done in

Re: SMTP Port Blocking: Success or Failure?

2005-02-27 Thread John Levine
What about rate limiting SMTP traffic rather than blocking it? That could allow legitimate use for most private customers, while preventing bulk traffic. Comcast has been doing something like that, looking for spikes of SMTP connects and blocking when they see them, done at the IP level. I

Re: SMTP Port Blocking: Success or Failure?

2005-02-27 Thread Stephen Fulton
Claydon, Tom wrote: It depends on your customer base. For residential customers, filtering outbound port 25 is considered acceptable. For business customer, not so. In my case, I deal with the latter. It can be problematic, because business computers do become part of part of some

Re: SMTP Port Blocking: Success or Failure?

2005-02-27 Thread David Burns
On Sat, 26 Feb 2005 19:04:26 -0600, Claydon, Tom [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: We are considering filtering outbound SMTP traffic from our ISP customers, except from our own mail servers, to help reduce the amount of spam originating from our network. How successful/unsucessful has implementing

Re: SMTP Port Blocking: Success or Failure?

2005-02-26 Thread Christopher L. Morrow
On Sat, 26 Feb 2005, Claydon, Tom wrote: We are considering filtering outbound SMTP traffic from our ISP customers, except from our own mail servers, to help reduce the amount of spam originating from our network. How successful/unsucessful has implementing outbound SMTP filtering done in