Re: operational: icmp echo out of control?

2002-05-28 Thread Chris Woodfield
The problem here is that other types of probes raise IDS alarms on way too many networks - the next-best method is to probe HTTP ports, but we don't want to have to pull down thousands of web pages just to get performance stats. So, they send a SYN, wait for the ACK, record the latency and

Re: operational: icmp echo out of control?

2002-05-28 Thread Richard A Steenbergen
On Tue, May 28, 2002 at 01:05:19PM -0400, Chris Woodfield wrote: The problem here is that other types of probes raise IDS alarms on way too many networks - the next-best method is to probe HTTP ports, but we don't want to have to pull down thousands of web pages just to get performance

Re: operational: icmp echo out of control?

2002-05-28 Thread Jeff Mcadams
Also sprach E.B. Dreger RAS be mistaken for a port scan. But for so many network admins, RAS all they know is ICMP bad. That'll be the day when someone calls abuse saying I'm being attacked by ICMP unreachables! ;-) That'll be...? Future tense? Hrmm... -- Jeff McAdams

Re: operational: icmp echo out of control?

2002-05-28 Thread Mike Tancsa
At 03:21 PM 28/05/2002 -0400, Jeff Mcadams wrote: Also sprach E.B. Dreger RAS be mistaken for a port scan. But for so many network admins, RAS all they know is ICMP bad. That'll be the day when someone calls abuse saying I'm being attacked by ICMP unreachables! ;-) That'll be...? Future

Re: operational: icmp echo out of control?

2002-05-28 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
On Tue, 28 May 2002 16:01:12 EDT, Richard A Steenbergen said: I don't know whats worse, those crappy personal firewalls that make every packet look like a life or death assault, or the idiots who send abuse email demanding that you do something for them or they will sue and/or hax0r you.

RE: operational: icmp echo out of control?

2002-05-28 Thread Rowland, Alan D
]] Sent: Tuesday, May 28, 2002 1:01 PM To: Mike Tancsa Cc: Jeff Mcadams; [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: operational: icmp echo out of control? On Tue, May 28, 2002 at 03:36:08PM -0400, Mike Tancsa wrote: Jeu 09 mai 2002 15:30:22, Port 3, ICMP, Destination Unreachable Jeu 09 mai 2002

Re: operational: icmp echo out of control?

2002-05-28 Thread John Kristoff
On Tue, 28 May 2002 16:16:08 -0400 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: It's common enough that it's got it's own acronym. IWF - Idiot With Firewall. We call them OZZADs and here is how we respond: http://condor.depaul.edu/~jkristof/technotes/incident-response.html John

Re: operational: icmp echo out of control?

2002-05-28 Thread John Kristoff
We call them OZZADs and here is how we respond: Hmm.. 3 people have asked already What's an OZZAD? ;) So I don't have to keep answering this, forwarded to the group: Over Zealous Zone Alarm Dork John

IWF was: RE: operational: icmp echo out of control?

2002-05-28 Thread Deepak Jain
-Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]On Behalf Of Mike Tancsa Sent: Tuesday, May 28, 2002 3:36 PM To: Jeff Mcadams Cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: operational: icmp echo out of control? [deleted] The access attempt(s) are shown below, including

Re: operational: icmp echo out of control?

2002-05-23 Thread Bryan Bradsby
On Thu, 23 May 2002, Mark Kent wrote: I've observed that our border routers are getting pinged 5 per second, seems consistent throughout the day, roughly 40 different sources every 15 seconds I took a look at the varied sources and discovered that the sites are well connected and

Re: operational: icmp echo out of control?

2002-05-23 Thread Richard A Steenbergen
On Thu, May 23, 2002 at 10:05:08AM -0700, Mark Kent wrote: I've observed that our border routers are getting pinged a fair bit. I measured on one router and saw: 5 per second, seems consistent throughout the day, roughly 40 different sources every 15 seconds I took a look at the

Re: operational: icmp echo out of control?

2002-05-23 Thread Mark Kent
RAS I can't speak as to what exactly Akamai is doing, but this I should add that Akamai contacted me with minutes of my initial post to ask for more data and they said that they are looking into it... leaving me with the impression that what I was seeing was not typical. -mark

Re: operational: icmp echo out of control?

2002-05-23 Thread Scott Granados
Its important to note a point entioned here that vendors are building boxes to do this as well. I ran a 3dns pair for a while and wow the mail that came in from people with firewalls or simply watching for probes. F5 was opening all sorts of half opened connections and wierd ports other

Re: operational: icmp echo out of control?

2002-05-23 Thread Amgad Zeitoun
I have uploaded a PDF version of our RTT measurement study. You can find it at: http://idmaps.eecs.umich.edu/papers/rtt.pdf Regards, Amgad Path latency doesn't change much, you can determine this with very few probes. . . . . Much like web spidering, some simple common sense can