Re: Quagga for production?

2020-03-18 Thread Mark Tinka
On 18/Mar/20 22:22, Nick Hilliard wrote: > Yeah.  I was thinking more for the case of customer-facing anycast > resolvers, in which case BGP down means that the network is down, and > if the network is down it doesn't matter than DNS is also down because > their shared fate means that when BGP

Re: Quagga for production?

2020-03-18 Thread Mark Tinka
On 18/Mar/20 22:22, Nick Hilliard wrote: > > Yeah.  I was thinking more for the case of customer-facing anycast > resolvers, in which case BGP down means that the network is down, and > if the network is down it doesn't matter than DNS is also down because > their shared fate means that when BG

Re: Quagga for production?

2020-03-18 Thread Nick Hilliard
Mark Tinka wrote on 18/03/2020 17:02: I prefer to have a number of core systems accessible in the IGP, because BGP can sometimes get hosed for one reason or another. BGP always needs IGP to work. The reverse is not true, and reduces us to absolute basics when it hits the fan (which it has, a few

Re: Quagga for production?

2020-03-18 Thread Mark Tinka
On 18/Mar/20 18:01, Nick Hilliard wrote:   > > I used to use ISIS for this, but more recently moved to ebgp with > 1s/3s timers.  The convergence characteristics are reasonable and as > the only routing protocol dependence is bgp, we can use bird which in > turn allow us to automate provisioning

Re: Quagga for production?

2020-03-18 Thread Nick Hilliard
Mark Tinka wrote on 18/03/2020 14:25: At the moment, I run Quagga with OSPF and export that into my IS-IS core to drive Anycast services. I used to use ISIS for this, but more recently moved to ebgp with 1s/3s timers. The convergence characteristics are reasonable and as the only routing pro

Re: Quagga for production?

2020-03-18 Thread Jens Link
Mark Tinka writes: > On 17/Mar/20 19:39, Jens Link wrote: > >> >> Jens, using frr for quite some time now without any problems > > IS-IS, per chance? Sorry, only BGP for now. Jens -- | Delbrueckstr. 41| 12051 Berl

Re: Quagga for production?

2020-03-18 Thread Mark Tinka
On 17/Mar/20 19:39, Jens Link wrote: > > Jens, using frr for quite some time now without any problems IS-IS, per chance? Mark.

Re: Quagga for production?

2020-03-18 Thread Mark Tinka
On 17/Mar/20 19:18, Hiers, David wrote: > > Quagga is built into one of our core products, works great.   That > particular vendor a sponsor of frr, and is replacing quagga with frr soon. > >   > > Maybe look at the vendor/partner list for quagga and frr, and decide > which project has better lon

Re: Quagga for production?

2020-03-17 Thread Jens Link
Dmitry Sherman writes: > Hello, > > Anybody working with Quagga for production peering with multiple peers > and dynamic eBGP/iBGP announcement? https://frrouting.org/ is a quagga fork and most (all) developers of quagga mode to frr. Jens, using frr for quite some time now without

RE: Quagga for production?

2020-03-17 Thread Hiers, David
-boun...@nanog.org] On Behalf Of Nathan Brookfield Sent: Sunday, February 23, 2020 4:41 AM To: Dmitry Sherman Cc: nanog@nanog.org Subject: Re: Quagga for production? Hi Mate, Yep on and off for about 15 years, very solid, very reliable. I tend to use Bird this hmorning we rays for this task but

[nanog] Re: Quagga for production?

2020-02-23 Thread Chriztoffer Hansen
Raymond Burkholder wrote: > On 2020-02-23 5:26 a.m., Dmitry Sherman wrote: >> Anybody working with Quagga for production peering with multiple peers >> and dynamic eBGP/iBGP announcement? >> > Free Range Routing (FRR) forked Quagga a few years back.  I would say it >

Re: Quagga for production?

2020-02-23 Thread Raymond Burkholder
On 2020-02-23 5:26 a.m., Dmitry Sherman wrote: Hello, Anybody working with Quagga for production peering with multiple peers and dynamic eBGP/iBGP announcement? Free Range Routing (FRR) forked Quagga a few years back.  I would say it is the new Quagga. But either flavour handles multiple

Re: Quagga for production?

2020-02-23 Thread Nathan Brookfield
:  Hello, Anybody working with Quagga for production peering with multiple peers and dynamic eBGP/iBGP announcement? Thanks. Dmitry

Re: Quagga for production?

2020-02-23 Thread Nathan Brookfield
:  Hello, Anybody working with Quagga for production peering with multiple peers and dynamic eBGP/iBGP announcement? Thanks. Dmitry

Quagga for production?

2020-02-23 Thread Dmitry Sherman
Hello, Anybody working with Quagga for production peering with multiple peers and dynamic eBGP/iBGP announcement? Thanks. Dmitry