Re: [eX-bulk] : Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-14 Thread nanog
Greetings, Do we really need them to be swappable at that point? The reason we swap HDD's (if we do) is because they are rotational, and mechanical things break. Do we swap CPUs and memory hot? Do we even replace memory on a server that's gone bad, or just pull the whole thing during the

Re: [eX-bulk] : Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-14 Thread charles
On 2015-05-13 19:42, na...@cdl.asgaard.org wrote: Greetings, Do we really need them to be swappable at that point? The reason we swap HDD's (if we do) is because they are rotational, and mechanical things break. Right. Do we swap CPUs and memory hot? Nope. Usually just toss the whole

Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-13 Thread Lamar Owen
On 05/11/2015 06:50 PM, Brandon Martin wrote: 8kW/rack is something it seems many a typical computing oriented datacenter would be used to dealing with, no? Formfactor within the rack is just a little different which may complicate how you can deliver the cooling - might need unusually

Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-12 Thread Barry Shein
To some extent people are comparing apples (not TM) and oranges. Are you trying to maximize the number of total cores or the number of total computes? They're not the same. It depends on the job mix you expect. For example a map-reduce kind of problem, search of a massive database, probably is

Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-12 Thread Rafael Possamai
Here's someone's comparison between the B and B+ in terms of power: http://raspi.tv/2014/how-much-less-power-does-the-raspberry-pi-b-use-than-the-old-model-b On Mon, May 11, 2015 at 10:25 PM, Joel Maslak jmas...@antelope.net wrote: Rather then guessing on power consumption, I measured it. I

Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-11 Thread Rafael Possamai
Interesting! Knowing a pi costs approximately $35, then you need approximately $350 to get near an i5.. The smallest and cheapest desktop you can get that would have similar power is the Intel NUC with an i5 that goes for approximately $350. Power consumption of a NUC is about 5x that of the

Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-11 Thread Michael Thomas
As it turns out, I've been playing around benchmarking things lately using the tried and true UnixBench suite and here are a few numbers that might put this in some perspective: 1) My new Rapsberry pi (4 cores, arm): 406 2) My home i5-like thing (asus 4 cores, 16gb's from last year): 3857 3)

Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-11 Thread Clay Fiske
On May 8, 2015, at 10:24 PM, char...@thefnf.org wrote: Pi dimensions: 3.37 l (5 front to back) 2.21 w (6 wide) 0.83 h 25 per U (rounding down for Ethernet cable space etc) = 825 pi Cable management and heat would probably kill this before it ever reached completion, but lol… This

Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-11 Thread Dave Taht
On Mon, May 11, 2015 at 1:37 PM, Clay Fiske c...@bloomcounty.org wrote: On May 8, 2015, at 10:24 PM, char...@thefnf.org wrote: Pi dimensions: 3.37 l (5 front to back) 2.21 w (6 wide) 0.83 h 25 per U (rounding down for Ethernet cable space etc) = 825 pi The parallella board is about the

Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-11 Thread Peter Baldridge
Pi dimensions: 3.37 l (5 front to back) 2.21 w (6 wide) 0.83 h 25 per U (rounding down for Ethernet cable space etc) = 825 pi You butt up against major power/heat issues here in a single rack, not that it's impossible. From what I could find the rPi2 requires .5A min. The few SSD specs

Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-11 Thread Joel Maslak
Rather then guessing on power consumption, I measured it. I took a Pi (Model B - but I suspect B+ and the new version is relatively similar in power draw with the same peripherials), hooked it up to a lab power supply, and took a current measurement. My pi has a Sandisk SD card and a Sandisk USB

Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-11 Thread Randy Carpenter
- On May 11, 2015, at 5:36 PM, Peter Baldridge petebaldri...@gmail.com wrote: Pi dimensions: 3.37 l (5 front to back) 2.21 w (6 wide) 0.83 h 25 per U (rounding down for Ethernet cable space etc) = 825 pi You butt up against major power/heat issues here in a single rack, not that

Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-11 Thread Peter Baldridge
On Mon, May 11, 2015 at 3:21 PM, Randy Carpenter rcar...@network1.net wrote: That is .8-1.6A at 5v DC. A far cry from 120V AC. We're talking ~5W versus ~120W each. Granted there is some conversion overhead, but worst case you are probably talking about 1/20th the power you describe. Yeah,

Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-11 Thread Chris Boyd
On Mon, 2015-05-11 at 14:36 -0700, Peter Baldridge wrote: I don't know how to do the math for the 'vat of oil scenario'. It's not something I've ever wanted to work with. It's pretty interesting what you can do with immersion cooling. I work with it at $DAYJOB. Similar to air cooling, but

Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-11 Thread Brandon Martin
On 05/11/2015 06:21 PM, Randy Carpenter wrote: That is .8-1.6A at 5v DC. A far cry from 120V AC. We're talking ~5W versus ~120W each. Granted there is some conversion overhead, but worst case you are probably talking about 1/20th the power you describe. His estimates seem to consider that

Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-11 Thread Rafael Possamai
Maybe I messed up the math in my head, my line of thought was one pi is estimated to use 1.2 watts, whereas the nuc is at around 65 watts. 10 pi's = 12 watts. My comparison was 65watts/12watts = 5.4 times more power than 10 pi's put together. This is really a rough estimate because I got the NUC's

Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-11 Thread Hugo Slabbert
Did I miss anything? Just a quick comparison. If those numbers are accurate, then it leans towards the NUC rather than the Pi, no? Perf: 1x i5 NUC = 10x Pi $$: 1x i5 NUC = 10x Pi Power: 1x i5 NUC = 5x Pi So...if a single NUC gives you the performance of 10x Pis at the capital cost

Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-09 Thread Dave Taht
On Sat, May 9, 2015 at 11:55 AM, Barry Shein b...@world.std.com wrote: On May 9, 2015 at 00:24 char...@thefnf.org (char...@thefnf.org) wrote: So I just crunched the numbers. How many pies could I cram in a rack? For another list I just estimated how many M.2 SSD modules one could

Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-09 Thread Rafael Possamai
From the work that I've done in the past with clusters, your need for bandwidth is usually not the biggest issue. When you work with big data, let's say 500 million data points, most mathematicians would condense it all down into averages, standard deviations, probabilities, etc, which then become

Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-09 Thread Barry Shein
On May 9, 2015 at 00:24 char...@thefnf.org (char...@thefnf.org) wrote: So I just crunched the numbers. How many pies could I cram in a rack? For another list I just estimated how many M.2 SSD modules one could cram into a 3.5 disk case. Around 40 w/ some room to spare (assuming heat and

Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-09 Thread Eugeniu Patrascu
On Sat, May 9, 2015 at 9:55 PM, Barry Shein b...@world.std.com wrote: On May 9, 2015 at 00:24 char...@thefnf.org (char...@thefnf.org) wrote: So I just crunched the numbers. How many pies could I cram in a rack? For another list I just estimated how many M.2 SSD modules one could

Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-08 Thread charles
So I just crunched the numbers. How many pies could I cram in a rack? Check my numbers? 48U rack budget 6513 15U (48-15) = 33U remaining for pie 6513 max of 576 copper ports Pi dimensions: 3.37 l (5 front to back) 2.21 w (6 wide) 0.83 h 25 per U (rounding down for Ethernet cable space etc)

Re: Rasberry pi - high density

2015-05-08 Thread Tim Raphael
The problem is, I can get more processing power and RAM out of two 10RU blade chassis and only needing 64 10G ports... 32 x 256GB RAM per blade = 8.1TB 32 x 16 cores x 2.4GHz = 1,228GHz (not based on current highest possible, just using reasonable specs) Needing only 4 QFX5100s which will cost