Re: Shaping on a large scale

2009-01-31 Thread Colin Alston
On 2009/01/30 07:56 PM bert hubert wrote: In general, the Linux packet shaping infrastructure is overly powerful, if very weakly documented - despite the LARTC efforts. Overly powerful is a strong word. Sure it has countless poorly documented features, but then it fails at even the the most

Re: Shaping on a large scale

2009-01-31 Thread Rubens Kuhl
Besides the other solutions listed, you can also take a look at Arbor (formerly Ellacoya) and Sandvine. Rubens On Fri, Jan 30, 2009 at 3:33 AM, Bruce Grobler br...@yoafrica.com wrote: Hi, Does anyone know of any Shaping appliances to shape customers based on IP, allow for a quota per IP

Re: Shaping on a large scale

2009-01-30 Thread Nuno Vieira - nfsi telecom
Check Ipoque solutions. http://www.ipoque.com/ regards, --- Nuno Vieira nfsi telecom, lda. nuno.vie...@nfsi.pt Tel. (+351) 21 949 2300 - Fax (+351) 21 949 2301 http://www.nfsi.pt/ - Bruce Grobler br...@yoafrica.com wrote: Hi, Does anyone know of any Shaping appliances to shape

RE: Shaping on a large scale

2009-01-30 Thread Scott Berkman
...@yoafrica.com] Sent: Friday, January 30, 2009 12:34 AM To: nanog@nanog.org Subject: Shaping on a large scale Hi, Does anyone know of any Shaping appliances to shape customers based on IP, allow for a quota per IP and qos mechanisms like LLQ?, This is should be something that can sit

RE: Shaping on a large scale

2009-01-30 Thread C. Jon Larsen
qdisc show dev eth0 -Original Message- From: Bruce Grobler [mailto:br...@yoafrica.com] Sent: Friday, January 30, 2009 12:34 AM To: nanog@nanog.org Subject: Shaping on a large scale Hi, Does anyone know of any Shaping appliances to shape customers based on IP, allow for a quota per IP

Re: Shaping on a large scale

2009-01-30 Thread bert hubert
On Fri, Jan 30, 2009 at 10:25:49AM -0500, Scott Berkman wrote: http://lartc.org/. Also I'm not sure if someone has built this into any of the firewall specific linux distros yet, so you may want to explore those a little. They have. Many Linux appliances come with a 'Linux Wonder Shaper'

RE: Shaping on a large scale

2009-01-30 Thread Chris Caputo
On Fri, 30 Jan 2009, C. Jon Larsen wrote: Open source you can do a custom setup with IPTables and iproute2, but it will take some work to get the same kind of features and management interface. LARTC is a good reference for this kind of topic: http://lartc.org/. Also I'm not sure if

RE: Shaping on a large scale

2009-01-30 Thread Bruce Grobler
- From: Chris Caputo [mailto:ccap...@alt.net] Sent: Friday, January 30, 2009 9:54 PM To: C. Jon Larsen Cc: Scott Berkman; nanog@nanog.org Subject: RE: Shaping on a large scale On Fri, 30 Jan 2009, C. Jon Larsen wrote: Open source you can do a custom setup with IPTables and iproute2

Re: Shaping on a large scale

2009-01-30 Thread Matthew Moyle-Croft
Bruce, Are these broadband customer using PPPoE or L2TP? If so, I suggest looking at the capabilities of your BRAS to do the work. Per user bandwidth quotas are the nature of the game here in Australia and doing it at the BRAS is the way we do it. RADIUS gives you byte counts and

Re: Shaping on a large scale

2009-01-30 Thread Adrian Chadd
On Sat, Jan 31, 2009, Matthew Moyle-Croft wrote: Bruce, Are these broadband customer using PPPoE or L2TP? If so, I suggest looking at the capabilities of your BRAS to do the work. Per user bandwidth quotas are the nature of the game here in Australia and doing it at the BRAS is the

Shaping on a large scale

2009-01-29 Thread Bruce Grobler
Hi, Does anyone know of any Shaping appliances to shape customers based on IP, allow for a quota per IP and qos mechanisms like LLQ?, This is should be something that can sit in between two border router's and support a small ISP (2 customers), also an opensource solution would be