RE: [nant-dev] FileSet includes question

2002-06-24 Thread Kevin Dente
Oops, I suggested the exact same thing before I had read this. Serves me right for not reading the whole thread before replying. In looking through the Ant code, the only tricky thing they do is to ensure that there isn't a circular reference. Not a hard check to do, but an important one. ---

RE: [nant-dev] FileSet includes question

2002-06-24 Thread Scott Hernandez
require each refid'd task would have to know how to deal with a Reference. I'm much more of the opinion that should do the xml merging, or double xml initialization. See the rest of my comments below. -Original Message- From: Tomas Restrepo Subject: Re: [nant-dev] FileSet includes

Re: [nant-dev] FileSet includes question

2002-06-24 Thread Tomas Restrepo
Ian, I think so. Right now property expansion doesn't happen until just before task execution so that would kinda mandate define before reference semantics. The other issue is property expansion itself. If you're using a referenced Fileset that has a number of ${property} 's - do you use

RE: [nant-dev] FileSet includes question

2002-06-23 Thread Kevin Dente
Yeah, I kinda figured that out while reviewing the Ant docs. :) The reason I say it make be useful is that it allows non-trivial FileSets to be specified through property expansion. You see, I'm working on replacing a fairly complex build system (built using NMake) with NAnt. The original

RE: [nant-dev] FileSet includes question

2002-06-23 Thread Gerry Shaw
solving your problem this way rather than the comma seperated include pattern. -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] On Behalf Of Kevin Dente Sent: Sun, June 23, 2002 6:12 PM To: Gerry Shaw; 'Nant developer's list' Subject: RE: [nant-dev] FileSet

Re: [nant-dev] FileSet includes question

2002-06-23 Thread Tomas Restrepo
I was thinking about the id'ed FileSet's. Here is what would need changing: * Add an Id property to the FileSet class I'm kind of curious about why implement it this way it seems to me, that everything in the buildfile should be able to be referenced by an ID, so I'd think a more

RE: [nant-dev] FileSet includes question

2002-06-23 Thread Gerry Shaw
I was thinking about the id'ed FileSet's. Here is what would need changing: * Add an Id property to the FileSet class I'm kind of curious about why implement it this way it seems to me, that everything in the buildfile should be able to be referenced by an ID, so I'd think a

RE: [nant-dev] FileSet includes question

2002-06-22 Thread Gerry Shaw
The docs are wrong. I shamelessly compied from directly from Ant :) and I must have missed that. I'm not sure it adds anything that you could already do with multiple include tags. I perfer things to be really obvious at the expense of more typing since you only have type stuff once but it