Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-15 Thread Rhialto
On Thu 05 Jul 2018 at 10:52:12 +0300, Andreas Gustafsson wrote: > MLH wrote: > > Boot Options are: > > Hard Drive, CDROM, USB-FDD, USB-ZIP, USB-CDROM, USB-HDD, Legacy LAN > > A USB memory stick emulates a hard drive, so USB-HDD should work. A USB stick formatted like a hard drive *should* always

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-13 Thread Hauke Fath
On 07/11/18 21:58, MLH wrote: Unfortunately, gpt-on-raid1-on-gpt is not bootable, as opposed to disklabel-on-RAID1-on-disklabel (which has size limitations). The mbr boot code is able to account for disklabel-on-raid1, but not for gpt-on-raid1, see e.g. install/44982. > I'm not quite sure I am

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-11 Thread MLH
Hauke Fath wrote: > On 07/01/18 22:55, MLH wrote: > > Things are generally going well but before I actually install a > > system, one question I have is how to make the configuration > > bootable. > > Unfortunately, gpt-on-raid1-on-gpt is not bootable, as opposed to > disklabel-on-RAID1-on-diskla

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-07 Thread Michael Parson
On Thu, 5 Jul 2018, Thomas Mueller wrote: I remember seeing something in (I believe it was Syslinux) about formatting/partitioning a USB stick to make it look like an Iomega Zip drive. Does anybody still make floppy disks, or USB floppy drives? Modern motherboards have no floppy headers.

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-06 Thread Robert Elz
In article , Hauke Fath wrote: | >Unfortunately, gpt-on-raid1-on-gpt is not bootable, as opposed to | >disklabel-on-RAID1-on-disklabel (which has size limitations). Date:Fri, 6 Jul 2018 11:48:01 + (UTC) From:chris...@astron.com (Christos Zoulas) Message-ID

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-06 Thread Christos Zoulas
In article , Hauke Fath wrote: >On 07/01/18 22:55, MLH wrote: >> Things are generally going well but before I actually install a >> system, one question I have is how to make the configuration >> bootable. > >Unfortunately, gpt-on-raid1-on-gpt is not bootable, as opposed to >disklabel-on-RAID1-o

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-06 Thread Hauke Fath
On 07/01/18 22:55, MLH wrote: Things are generally going well but before I actually install a system, one question I have is how to make the configuration bootable. Unfortunately, gpt-on-raid1-on-gpt is not bootable, as opposed to disklabel-on-RAID1-on-disklabel (which has size limitations).

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-06 Thread tlaronde
On Thu, Jul 05, 2018 at 07:09:27PM -0400, MLH wrote: > Thomas Mueller wrote: > > Does CDROM on your boot options include DVD? > > Yes. That's what I used to recover my temp boot disk and it works > great. In a separate message I mentioned I was attempting to build > a custom Live DVD but I can't f

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-05 Thread Thomas Mueller
from MLH: > Thomas Mueller wrote: > > Does CDROM on your boot options include DVD? > Yes. That's what I used to recover my temp boot disk and it works > great. In a separate message I mentioned I was attempting to build > a custom Live DVD but I can't figure out the new way of creating > a boot

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-05 Thread MLH
MLH wrote: > Andreas Gustafsson wrote: > > MLH wrote: > > > Boot Options are: > > > Hard Drive, CDROM, USB-FDD, USB-ZIP, USB-CDROM, USB-HDD, Legacy LAN > > > > A USB memory stick emulates a hard drive, so USB-HDD should work. > > I tried it again and apparently I didn't wait long enough before.

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-05 Thread MLH
Thomas Mueller wrote: > Does CDROM on your boot options include DVD? Yes. That's what I used to recover my temp boot disk and it works great. In a separate message I mentioned I was attempting to build a custom Live DVD but I can't figure out the new way of creating a bootable CD/DVD since floppy

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-05 Thread Thomas Mueller
from MLH: > Andreas Gustafsson wrote: > > MLH wrote: > > > Boot Options are: > > > Hard Drive, CDROM, USB-FDD, USB-ZIP, USB-CDROM, USB-HDD, Legacy LAN > > A USB memory stick emulates a hard drive, so USB-HDD should work. > I tried it again and apparently I didn't wait long enough before. > Afte

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-05 Thread MLH
Andreas Gustafsson wrote: > MLH wrote: > > Boot Options are: > > Hard Drive, CDROM, USB-FDD, USB-ZIP, USB-CDROM, USB-HDD, Legacy LAN > > A USB memory stick emulates a hard drive, so USB-HDD should work. I tried it again and apparently I didn't wait long enough before. After about five minutes, i

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-05 Thread Andreas Gustafsson
MLH wrote: > Boot Options are: > Hard Drive, CDROM, USB-FDD, USB-ZIP, USB-CDROM, USB-HDD, Legacy LAN A USB memory stick emulates a hard drive, so USB-HDD should work. -- Andreas Gustafsson, g...@gson.org

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-05 Thread Chavdar Ivanov
My HP Envy laptop boots netbsd in both efi and bios modes, from internal sata disk and external usb one. Both modes are enabled simultaneously. My default efi boot is rEFInd, works fine for me. I installed NetBSD-current on some free space at the end of a gpt disk which already contained a couple o

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-05 Thread MLH
Thomas Mueller wrote: > from MLH: > > > Scratch the request for usb stick boot. My motherboard doesn't > > appear to allow it. I'll see if I can build a cd that I can boot > > off of and transfer to the hard drive for the system. > > > Thanks anyway > > I thought all modern PC motherboards could

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-04 Thread Thomas Mueller
from MLH: > Scratch the request for usb stick boot. My motherboard doesn't > appear to allow it. I'll see if I can build a cd that I can boot > off of and transfer to the hard drive for the system. > Thanks anyway I thought all modern PC motherboards could boot from USB stick. What do you see

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-04 Thread MLH
Thomas Mueller wrote: > from MLH: > > > Needless to say, the EFI drives didn't boot. Not sure why yet. > > "Booting Operating System" showed then the cursor moved down, > > possibly attempting to display something, then kept cycling back > > and from bwtween those two. > > My systems have UEFI, b

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-04 Thread Thomas Mueller
from MLH: > Well, not so great. Once the bios detects an EFI boot drive on the > system, it attempts to load that, regardless of any other non-EFI > boot drive you specify. So to boot from the temp non-EFI boot drive, > the EFI drives have to be disconnected until the NetBSD boot loader > has star

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-03 Thread MLH
MLH wrote: > Robert Elz wrote: > > | The motherboard supposedly autodetects either efi or bios boot so > > | I thought I might just go with efi first. > > > > That's interesting, as it is possible to have both setup... I wonder > > which it chooses then? > > Actually the manual isn't clear : >

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-03 Thread MLH
Robert Elz wrote: > | The motherboard supposedly autodetects either efi or bios boot so > | I thought I might just go with efi first. > > That's interesting, as it is possible to have both setup... I wonder > which it chooses then? Actually the manual isn't clear : - EFI CD/DVD Boot Option Se

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-02 Thread Robert Elz
Date:Mon, 2 Jul 2018 21:55:34 -0400 (EDT) From:m...@goathill.org (MLH) Message-ID: <20180703015534.336c612...@chopper.goathill.org> | The motherboard supposedly autodetects either efi or bios boot so | I thought I might just go with efi first. That's interesting,

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-02 Thread MLH
m...@netbsd.org wrote: > This guide might be helpful for you > https://wiki.netbsd.org/users/spz/moderndisk/ The motherboard supposedly autodetects either efi or bios boot so I thought I might just go with efi first. The url above plus Robert's and Greg's instructions have me this far (wd2 shown

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-02 Thread MLH
m...@netbsd.org wrote: > This guide might be helpful for you > https://wiki.netbsd.org/users/spz/moderndisk/ Thanks!

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-01 Thread Robert Elz
Date:Sun, 1 Jul 2018 23:16:24 -0400 (EDT) From:m...@goathill.org (MLH) Message-ID: <20180702031624.9247212...@chopper.goathill.org> | Thanks. I lost you regarding how to do the 2nd-stage boot. It is no different than if you were doing it on disklabel/mbr partitions

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-01 Thread maya
This guide might be helpful for you https://wiki.netbsd.org/users/spz/moderndisk/

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-01 Thread Robert Elz
Date:Sun, 1 Jul 2018 16:55:05 -0400 (EDT) From:m...@goathill.org (MLH) Message-ID: <20180701205505.af9d712...@chopper.goathill.org> | Things are generally going well but before I actually install a | system, one question I have is how to make the configuration |

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-01 Thread MLH
Greg Troxel wrote: > > m...@goathill.org (MLH) writes: > > > I'm looking at exactly how to set up a couple of 4G disks in a > > I am not really sure, but some advice: > > Generally, the way booting on raid works is that (with a little bit of > fuzz because I amy be off on details) > > it is

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-01 Thread Greg Troxel
m...@goathill.org (MLH) writes: > I'm looking at exactly how to set up a couple of 4G disks in a > bootable gpt/raid1 (raidframe, BIOS boot) configuration. I have a > temporary 80G boot drive I'm currently working from. It is currently > running NetBSD 8.99.17 > > I am attempting to follw the ins

Re: booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-01 Thread MLH
> I'm looking at exactly how to set up a couple of 4G disks in a > bootable gpt/raid1 (raidframe, BIOS boot) configuration. I have a Ug. I mean 4000G

booting from gpt/raid?

2018-07-01 Thread MLH
I'm looking at exactly how to set up a couple of 4G disks in a bootable gpt/raid1 (raidframe, BIOS boot) configuration. I have a temporary 80G boot drive I'm currently working from. It is currently running NetBSD 8.99.17 I am attempting to follw the instrucitons in GPT(8), https://www.netbsd.org/d