Re: How do we govern ourselves? (was: Mechanical Turkish)

2018-03-02 Thread carlo von lynX
On Fri, Feb 02, 2018 at 07:32:33AM -0600, Blake Stimson wrote: > more and more varied cultural consumption than other generations and less > access to power than other generations. Like any such generational marker, > its realism for them is a badge of honor and a measure of strength and > accompli

Re: How do we govern ourselves? (was: Mechanical Turkish)

2018-02-22 Thread Florian Cramer
On Wed, Jan 31, 2018 at 2:27 AM, Brian Holmes wrote: > On Mon, Jan 29, 2018 at 10:18 PM, Blake Stimson wrote: > >> My premise is that the question "how do we govern ourselves? ... with which >> institutions, under which rules, backed by which constraints?" that Brian >> raises can never be

Re: Mechanical Turkish

2018-02-20 Thread Morlock Elloi
But didn't the tech-savvy non-right (I can't bring myself to use idiotic terms as "left", "progressives", "liberals", "democrats") make a bet that slicing the society into micro-groups ("left-handed transsexuals" etc.) and managing these gullible groups with the high-tech networked systems, is

Re: How do we govern ourselves? (was: Mechanical Turkish)

2018-02-20 Thread Blake Stimson
Dear Brian and Felix, Thank you for your thoughtful responses. I know Brian is ready to wind up this discussion but allow me to conclude my part with just one final thought. I take us to agree on every point except one: that we need new models for politics. It is a fully understandable desire to i

Re: How do we govern ourselves? (was: Mechanical Turkish)

2018-02-20 Thread Brian Holmes
On 02/17/2018 07:44 AM, Blake Stimson wrote: I do not put much stock in the Bourdieuian category of “cultural capital” and instead do indeed believe that power lies solely in the possession of money or the capacity for violence. Politics, as I use the term, is simply the state. Put more

Re: Mechanical Turkish

2018-02-20 Thread Felix Stalder
On 2018-02-17 14:44, Blake Stimson wrote: > In our waning liberal modernity, good art, like good politics, is that > realism which enhances our capacity to think our own individual being > institutionally or, in other words, to see like a > (democratic-cum-socialist) state. "To think our own in

Re: How do we govern ourselves? (was: Mechanical Turkish)

2018-02-17 Thread Blake Stimson
Thank you for the generous response and ongoing dialogue Brian. As perhaps Yvette suggests, there is a lot there. Let me take a stab at answering your queries but if it seems too much in the weeds for the list maybe we could also get together in Chicago sometime to discuss whatever details further.

Re: How do we govern ourselves? (was: Mechanical Turkish)

2018-02-16 Thread Brian Holmes
Dear Blake (and everyone else) - Greetings. If I may, let me take up this interesting discussion again, with excuses for the lengthy pause. By the way, anyone can intervene in this discussion, surely these issues are of concern to some. Though it sounds depressing on the face of it, it's actually

Re: How do we govern ourselves? (was: Mechanical Turkish)

2018-02-07 Thread Patrice Riemens
Aloha, On Fri, Feb 02, 2018 at 07:32:33AM -0600, Blake Stimson wrote: > > > The core question of a democratic society is not "how do I become free?" > > Rather it is "how do we govern ourselves?" Crucially that means: with which > > institutions, under which rules, backed by which constraints [a

Re: How do we govern ourselves? (was: Mechanical Turkish)

2018-02-07 Thread Blake Stimson
Thanks for the generous response Brian, and very glad that we now agree that we agree on the parts listed. Let me try to attend to the part still in dispute. In the end I think we do largely agree even about this---that is, we are both focused on what you call “binding norms”---and only differ in

Re: How do we govern ourselves? (was: Mechanical Turkish)

2018-02-01 Thread Brian Holmes
Hello Blake - I think you've made a nettime first by listing the points where we agree! That's much appreciated. The list will likely stop right where it is, but still, I'd like to expand my take on this point of disagreement: Where we differ Brian, if I understand you correctly, is in where agen

Re: Mechanical Turkish

2018-01-31 Thread mp
On 30/01/18 10:34, Dmytri Kleiner wrote: > > On 2018-01-29 22:40, Brian Holmes wrote: > >> The urgent question today is how to >> create collective forms of democratic government for complex societies >> captivated by the myth of the sovereign individual. > > Read C.B. Macpherson? For those i

Re: Mechanical Turkish

2018-01-31 Thread Dmytri Kleiner
On 2018-01-29 22:40, Brian Holmes wrote: > The urgent question today is how to > create collective forms of democratic government for complex societies > captivated by the myth of the sovereign individual. Read C.B. Macpherson? -- Dmytri Kleiner http://dmytri.info @dmytri # distributed via

Re: Mechanical Turkish

2018-01-31 Thread Lara Stumpf
My first thought after reading the report was: How could I troll the system? Well, by spreading love, obviously. Just like a friend of mine created fake facebook-accounts to create love-posts, one could make lovely posts and report them. I know, this is not very useful, it doesn’t help with th

How do we govern ourselves? (was: Mechanical Turkish)

2018-01-30 Thread Brian Holmes
On Mon, Jan 29, 2018 at 10:18 PM, Blake Stimson wrote: My premise is that the question "how do we govern ourselves? ... with > which institutions, under which rules, backed by which constraints?" that > Brian raises can never be asked from the outsider standpoint of > institutional critique but

Re: Mechanical Turkish

2018-01-29 Thread Brian Holmes
On Sat, Jan 27, 2018 at 4:24 PM, Florian Cramer wrote: None of the issues described in this write-up can be blamed on the > corporate ownership of the currently popular social media. If people used > Open Source, community-owned and community-run social media instead (like, > for example, Mastodo

Re: Mechanical Turkish

2018-01-28 Thread Keith Sanborn
A simple matter of an algorithm. I almost said automation > On Jan 28, 2018, at 1:49 PM, Morlock Elloi wrote: > > The Ludovico Technique has certainly been improved. > > I wonder if the handset operators have already started to time and serve > political/ideological content in sync with posit

Re: Mechanical Turkish

2018-01-28 Thread Morlock Elloi
The Ludovico Technique has certainly been improved. I wonder if the handset operators have already started to time and serve political/ideological content in sync with positive (or negative) social messaging: you receive a message from child/lover - and at the same time link to the article pra

Re: Mechanical Turkish

2018-01-28 Thread Keith Sanborn
Reading the report—shd I call it that?—I kept thinking of Bataille: the impact of facing up to, or facing down images of extreme violence, sexuality, or sexual violence. Bataille’s contemplation of the image of the 100 cuts (so-called). But without the space or time for contemplation and the cre

Re: Mechanical Turkish

2018-01-27 Thread Morlock Elloi
Agree. It's about machine-mediated 'socializing', not about who runs it. As I mentioned earlier, open sourcing/democratizing the dystopia is not solving anything - it might even make it worse. On 1/27/18, 14:24, Florian Cramer wrote: Thanks for sharing this. None of the issues described in t

Re: Mechanical Turkish

2018-01-27 Thread Florian Cramer
Thanks for sharing this. None of the issues described in this write-up can be blamed on the corporate ownership of the currently popular social media. If people used Open Source, community-owned and community-run social media instead (like, for example, Mastodon or diaspora), there would be the sam

Mechanical Turkish

2018-01-27 Thread Morlock Elloi
TL;DR: Fb extracts ethical decisions from its digital precariat humanness deposits at the rate of one decision every 22 seconds (that's 0.045 decisions/sec.) (from https://sz-magazin.sueddeutsche.de/texte/anzeigen/46820/Three-months-in-hell ) Germany has become one of Facebook's most impo