Re: [PATCH] firewall-manager: allow dhcpv6-client service

2012-03-15 Thread Jiri Popelka
On 03/08/2012 02:53 PM, Tore Anderson wrote: The best solution would obviously be to just fix the default firewall in Fedora too, but the firewall infrastructure maintainer is refusing to make that change. In short, he doesn't seem likely to change his mind any time soon. He actually did :-)

Re: [PATCH] firewall-manager: allow dhcpv6-client service

2012-03-15 Thread Dan Williams
On Thu, 2012-03-15 at 18:33 +0100, Jiri Popelka wrote: On 03/08/2012 02:53 PM, Tore Anderson wrote: The best solution would obviously be to just fix the default firewall in Fedora too, but the firewall infrastructure maintainer is refusing to make that change. In short, he doesn't seem

Re: [PATCH] firewall-manager: allow dhcpv6-client service

2012-03-08 Thread Jiri Popelka
On 03/07/2012 10:55 PM, Tore Anderson wrote: 3) I saw the following error message appear in the logs a few times: warn (p17p1) firewall zone add/change failed: (32) ZONE_ALREADY_SET It happens when you for example restart NM and it tells firewalld to add interface to zone, but firewalld

Re: [PATCH] firewall-manager: allow dhcpv6-client service

2012-03-08 Thread Tore Anderson
* Ludwig Nussel Uh, ssh would probably be the last thing I'd allow in the public zone by default :-) Fully agreed. On hosts that have the SSH daemon open from the world, I see a constant stream of brute force attacks on it. DHCP (both versions) appears to be left alone by attackers, on the

Re: [PATCH] firewall-manager: allow dhcpv6-client service

2012-03-07 Thread Ludwig Nussel
Jiri Popelka wrote: Tell firewall to allow dhcpv6-client service for the given zone prior to starting dhcpv6 client. We don't need to wait for the response That looks odd to me. Why doesn't the zone config already allow dhcpv6 by default? cu Ludwig -- (o_ Ludwig Nussel //\ V_/_

Re: [PATCH] firewall-manager: allow dhcpv6-client service

2012-03-07 Thread Jiri Popelka
On 03/07/2012 10:26 AM, Ludwig Nussel wrote: Jiri Popelka wrote: Tell firewall to allow dhcpv6-client service for the given zone prior to starting dhcpv6 client. We don't need to wait for the response That looks odd to me. Why doesn't the zone config already allow dhcpv6 by default? That

Re: [PATCH] firewall-manager: allow dhcpv6-client service

2012-03-07 Thread Ludwig Nussel
Jiri Popelka wrote: On 03/07/2012 10:26 AM, Ludwig Nussel wrote: Jiri Popelka wrote: Tell firewall to allow dhcpv6-client service for the given zone prior to starting dhcpv6 client. We don't need to wait for the response That looks odd to me. Why doesn't the zone config already allow dhcpv6

Re: [PATCH] firewall-manager: allow dhcpv6-client service

2012-03-07 Thread Tore Anderson
* Jiri Popelka Yes and thank *you* to the outstanding work you've done in RHBZ#538499. Just a few itsy bitsy teenie weenie patches left to apply before NM/Fedora's IPv6 support is on par with Windows' and Mac OS X's... We are talking about FirewallD [1] which should [2] be the default

Re: [PATCH] firewall-manager: allow dhcpv6-client service

2012-03-06 Thread Tore Anderson
Hi Jiri, Tell firewall to allow dhcpv6-client service for the given zone prior to starting dhcpv6 client. We don't need to wait for the response because dhcp client keeps sending Solicit messages until it gets the response (i.e. until firewall opens the port). Thank you very much for looking

Re: [PATCH] firewall-manager: allow dhcpv6-client service

2012-03-06 Thread Jiri Popelka
On 03/06/2012 09:03 AM, Tore Anderson wrote: Hi Jiri, Tell firewall to allow dhcpv6-client service for the given zone prior to starting dhcpv6 client. We don't need to wait for the response because dhcp client keeps sending Solicit messages until it gets the response (i.e. until firewall opens

[PATCH] firewall-manager: allow dhcpv6-client service

2012-03-05 Thread Jiri Popelka
Tell firewall to allow dhcpv6-client service for the given zone prior to starting dhcpv6 client. We don't need to wait for the response because dhcp client keeps sending Solicit messages until it gets the response (i.e. until firewall opens the port). --- src/Makefile.am