[NSP] Re: Transposing

2010-04-11 Thread Philip Gruar
Anthony wrote As Stewart Hardy remarks when asked to play such material at weddings, "yes, I could play that for you but you might be very disappointed with the result"! I can certainly agree with that sentiment! I was once asked to play "You'll never walk alone" - on Highland pipes, at a 40t

[NSP] Re: Transposing

2010-04-11 Thread Colin
Well, I must admit, if I only played stuff that was in the "correct" key, I'd be playing very little. Not being very good at reading the dots, I play more by using the sol-fah method using my ear (obviously, I'm talking slower tunes here, ahem). I do this for all my instruments. The key I play i

[NSP] The Dark Island

2010-04-11 Thread Anthony Robb
Today Colin Hill wrote: Yeah, Dark Island is a nice example of drone clashing. Then again, it was written for one drone sound so I suppose that accounts for it. Usr the ones that sound best. Hello Colin ...or indeed no drones at all!! The tune was originally composed for the

[NSP] Re: The Dark Island

2010-04-11 Thread Bill
Anthony said: Hello Colin ...or indeed no drones at all!! The tune was originally composed for the button-box by Ian McLachlan as Dr. Mackay's Farewell to Creagorry. It was given words and a name change when it was used for the BBC film "The Dark island". The claim in 1965 by jo

[NSP] The Dark Island

2010-04-11 Thread Anthony Robb
Bill Telfer wrote: Aye I've heard Ian Maclaughlan play it years ago at Auchtermuchty Festival (on the platform in the town market place) - a very nice a TMSA festival where people take over the square for dancing) and he announced it as The Dark Island. As often happens som