[NSP] Re: Drone reeds: natural verus composite

2006-05-17 Thread Sam Edwards
my GHP for that reason, because the moisture control system (Ross canister) makes striking in and stopping difficult. Regards, Sam Edwards -Original Message- From: Miguel Costa [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Tuesday, May 16, 2006 3:36 PM To: nsp@cs.dartmouth.edu Subject: [NSP] Re: D

[NSP] Re: Drone reeds: natural verus composite

2006-05-17 Thread Christopher . Birch
: nsp@cs.dartmouth.edu Subject: [NSP] Re: Drone reeds: natural verus composite When Colin Ross refurbished my Hedworth set some years back, he replaced the original cane reeds with metal body/cane tongue ones and, to be honest, I have found them far more stable and (I didn't think I would li

[NSP] Re: Drone reeds: natural verus composite

2006-05-16 Thread Miguel Costa
I'm divided on this issue. I really like the sound of all-cane reeds, and I'm a bit conservative on that matter, but I'd rather have the reliability of plastic reeds. Metal reeds, for what I tried so far, have this obnoxious robotic sound (I call them "Spectrum reeds", although they could also be c

[NSP] Re: Drone reeds: natural verus composite

2006-05-16 Thread Colin
When Colin Ross refurbished my Hedworth set some years back, he replaced the original cane reeds with metal body/cane tongue ones and, to be honest, I have found them far more stable and (I didn't think I would like them as they were not the "traditional" ones), I actually prefer the sound they mak

[NSP] Re: Drone reeds: natural verus composite

2006-05-16 Thread Gibbons, John
Just make sure you don't light the reed - they burn prettily, I'm told. Not enough is better than too much. John -Original Message- From: Richard Shuttleworth [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: 16 May 2006 17:23 To: nsp@cs.dartmouth.edu; Sam Edwards Subject: [NSP] Re: Drone reed

[NSP] Re: Drone reeds: natural verus composite

2006-05-16 Thread Richard Shuttleworth
Hi Sam, As you say that you are going to keep playing your existing reeds, I thought that I would offer a comment on why they are using a lot of air. I don't think you will be short of opinions from other people as to the relative merits of cane vs. plasic, vs. composite, etc. :-) When it vi

[NSP] Re: Drone reeds: natural verus composite

2006-05-16 Thread Gibbons, John
I'll probably get flamed for this too, but having tried both, I find the composite reeds have a brighter tone, with more harmonics, and are a bit more reliable (unless I accidentally smash them). But if you prefer a mellow rather than a bright tone, you may like all-cane instead. Andy May once ma