ben-

thanks so much for doing this. i have a question/comment....

first, i am hoping that if these birds are posted like this in the future, that more specific information will be included like township and the party name who reported the bird/submitted the report. For example, regarding the crossbill, "Linden Lane, Dutchess County" . i would bet that there are a lot of "Linden Lanes" in this county of 350,000 people and perhaps a dozen towns.

then, i am wondering about who reviews these reports? I grew up in chappaqua (town of new castle), the same town where "campfire lake" is. i am assuming that it is the same campfire lake in the town of new castle, since town/municipality information was not provided on this report as well. but i know of no other "campfire lake" in westchester. if it is one in the same,  i birded that area for 30 years-and continue to do so to this day. i can tell you that there has not been a 'wild' pheasant in that area of westchester in more than 25 years. they are extirpated there, and i would imagine at this point extirpated from all of westchester. it also so happens that campfire lake is owned entirely i believe, by a hunt club-"The Campfire Club", which releases all sorts of game birds, i am sure. 

so these issues of concern leave me curious.

jpa
    
John Askildsen
Millbrook, New York

On Jan 31, 2011, Ben Cacace <bcac...@gmail.com> wrote:

Reply via email to