Re: [OAUTH-WG] draft-ietf-oauth-v2-13 comments

2011-03-24 Thread Mark Kent
>> 3. I believe that section 5.2 is ambiguous as to the error code that should >> be >> returned from the token endpoint when the client credentials are valid, >> when the client is authorized to use the authorization code grant type in >> general, but when the authorization code supplied is not va

[OAUTH-WG] draft-ietf-oauth-v2-13 comments

2011-03-06 Thread Mark Kent
First up, nice work with the latest version ­ it¹s considerably easier to follow than previous version. Based on a simple attempt to implement a compliant authentication server, I have the following requests for clarification: 1. The error response mechanism for the authorization endpoint depends

[OAUTH-WG] Stored association for Access Token Request

2011-02-04 Thread Mark Kent
Section 4.1.3 (v12) says: The authorization server MUST: o Validate the client credentials and ensure they match the authorization code. o Verify that the authorization code and redirection URI are valid and match its stored association. The ³stored association² does not a