Re: [OpenAFS] Openafs vs Red Hat's Netkey

2013-12-11 Thread Marcus Watts
Steve Gaarder writes: ... Then try copying a large file from AFS to the client's local storage, ... Now it gets weird. Iperf shows the same performance with or without IPSEC. But if I run iperf under IPSEC, openafs performance jumps back up to normal and stays there for several minutes.

Re: [OpenAFS] Openafs vs Red Hat's Netkey

2013-12-11 Thread Steve Gaarder
I fired up Wireshark and took a look. I set up IPSEC to use authentication only, so I can still see inside the packets. What I see, on both server and client, is this: When performance is poor, I see two fetch-data-64 packets from the server followed by an ACK packet from the client. There

Re: [OpenAFS] Openafs vs Red Hat's Netkey

2013-12-10 Thread Peter Grandi
I run a network of machines running Scientific Linux 6 (a Red Hat Enterprise clone). We have both AFS and NFS file servers. In an effort to add some security to NFS, we are using IPSEC. IPSEC may or may not be a good idea, but in an ideal world you would be using NFSv4 with a kernel newer

[OpenAFS] Openafs vs Red Hat's Netkey

2013-12-09 Thread Steve Gaarder
I run a network of machines running Scientific Linux 6 (a Red Hat Enterprise clone). We have both AFS and NFS file servers. In an effort to add some security to NFS, we are using IPSEC. I have discovered that IPSEC, specifically Red Hat's NETKEY protocol stack, sends OpenAFS performance

Re: [OpenAFS] Openafs vs Red Hat's Netkey

2013-12-09 Thread Derrick Brashear
curiosity, what is the mtu in the ipsec network? is netkey implemented similarly to ppp, namely that it encapsulates traffic and thus drops below a standard mtu? On Mon, Dec 9, 2013 at 11:24 AM, Steve Gaarder gaard...@math.cornell.eduwrote: I run a network of machines running Scientific Linux

Re: [OpenAFS] Openafs vs Red Hat's Netkey

2013-12-09 Thread Steve Gaarder
On Mon, 9 Dec 2013, Andrew Deason wrote: On Mon, 9 Dec 2013 11:24:55 -0500 (EST) Steve Gaarder gaard...@math.cornell.edu wrote: Then try copying a large file from AFS to the client's local storage, e.g. with rsync --progress. You will see performance steadily drop to miserable levels.