Re: [openflow-discuss] Determining if a host is on a non-OF switch

2011-07-01 Thread Aaron Rosen
Thanks Guys, That makes sense. Aaron On Fri, Jul 1, 2011 at 1:48 PM, Dan Talayco wrote: > There has been a lot of discussion on this over time. It depends a bit on > the nature of the non-OF switch. For example, if it uses LLDP packets or > participates in STP, you could at least recognize som

Re: [openflow-discuss] Determining if a host is on a non-OF switch

2011-07-01 Thread Dan Talayco
There has been a lot of discussion on this over time. It depends a bit on the nature of the non-OF switch. For example, if it uses LLDP packets or participates in STP, you could at least recognize something about the link. You could also have heuristics like "I see lots of MACs on this link" tho

Re: [openflow-discuss] Determining if a host is on a non-OF switch

2011-07-01 Thread Rob Sherwood
Normally, non-openflow switches send all sorts of their own, vendor specific... messages, e.g., HSRP, STP, LLDP, etc. My suggestion would be to look for these messages and use them to determine if the port on the OpenFlow switch is connected to a non-OpenFlow switch, and that will tell you that an

[openflow-discuss] Determining if a host is on a non-OF switch

2011-07-01 Thread Aaron Rosen
Hello, I have the following topology and I was wondering if there is any dynamic way to determine if a host originated from a non-OF switch. In this setup its's going to appear that hostC is attached to the middle OF switch. (I can discover the links between the OF switches but I'm not sure how to