Hi Roland Sean,
What is your opinion on this patch set ? Anything else needs to be done
for acceptance ?
Thanks,
- KK
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote on 08/16/2006 11:42:35 AM:
Hi James,
Sorry for the delay, we had a long weekend.
My opinion is that the create_qp taking generic parameters
Krishna Hi Roland Sean, What is your opinion on this patch set
Krishna ? Anything else needs to be done for acceptance ?
It's a very low priority for me, since it's a pain to merge and a pain
to maintain, and I don't see any urgency in renaming functions.
I'll try to get to it after
Krishna Kumar2 wrote:
What is your opinion on this patch set ? Anything else needs to be done
for acceptance ?
I don't have any issues with it, but Roland would need to commit the changes to
verbs as the first step.
- Sean
___
openib-general
Hi Roland,
Krishna Hi Roland Sean, What is your opinion on this patch set
Krishna ? Anything else needs to be done for acceptance ?
It's a very low priority for me, since it's a pain to merge and a pain
to maintain
I understand. If you feel that I can reduce the pain by sending an
Hi James,
Sorry for the delay, we had a long weekend.
My opinion is that the create_qp taking generic parameters is
correct, only subsequent calls may need to use transport specific
calls/arguments. Infact rdma_create_qp uses the ibv_create_qp (now
changed to rdmav_create_qp) call
On Wed, 9 Aug 2006, Krishna Kumar2 wrote:
Hi James,
Sorry for the late response, my system was down and I just got it fixed.
Is there a benefit to having rdmav_create_qp() take generic
parameters if the application needs to understand the type of QP (IB,
iWARP, etc.) created and
On Fri, 2006-08-11 at 10:20 -0400, James Lentini wrote:
On Wed, 9 Aug 2006, Krishna Kumar2 wrote:
Hi James,
Sorry for the late response, my system was down and I just got it fixed.
Is there a benefit to having rdmav_create_qp() take generic
parameters if the application needs
On Fri, 11 Aug 2006, Tom Tucker wrote:
On Fri, 2006-08-11 at 10:20 -0400, James Lentini wrote:
On Wed, 9 Aug 2006, Krishna Kumar2 wrote:
Hi James,
Sorry for the late response, my system was down and I just got it fixed.
Is there a benefit to having rdmav_create_qp()
[...snip...]
I think the QP is associated with the transport type indirectly through
the context. It can be queried with ibv_get_transport_type verb. A
renamed rdma_get_transport type would probably suffice.
We don't have a userspace ibv_get_transport_type() verb. There is a
kernel
Hi James,
Sorry for the late response, my system was down and I just got it fixed.
Is there a benefit to having rdmav_create_qp() take generic
parameters if the application needs to understand the type of QP (IB,
iWARP, etc.) created and the transport specific communication manager
calls
Hi James,
Are the rdmav_ versions intended to be generic or are they intended
for use with the native communications managers (IB CM and iWARP CM)?
It is true that the rdmav_ version is generic. But using the rdmav_
routines
means knowing the type of transport interface (eg, I need to do
On Mon, 7 Aug 2006, Krishna Kumar2 wrote:
Hi James,
Are the rdmav_ versions intended to be generic or are they intended
for use with the native communications managers (IB CM and iWARP CM)?
It is true that the rdmav_ version is generic. But using the rdmav_
routines means knowing
This patchset is a proposal to create new API's and data structures with
transport neutral names. The idea is to remove the old API once all
libraries/applications/examples are gradually converted to use the new API.
Patch 1/6 - Changes to libibverbs configuration file to build the libibverbs
[REPOSTING - as 2 patches in my first set didn't seem to have got to openib
mailing list though I checked after 2 hours. Apologies in advance since people
will get duplicates of atleast 4 of the successful patches]
This patchset is a proposal to create new API's and data structures with
transport
On Thu, 3 Aug 2006, Krishna Kumar wrote:
2. Changed rdma_ to rdmav_. This also enabled to retain rdma_create_qp() and
rdma_destroy_qp() routines.
I'm glad to see that the generic RDMA verbs are becoming a reality.
Exporting QP create/destroy functions from both the RDMA CM library
and
15 matches
Mail list logo
