Re: [osol-discuss] WriteBack versus SSD-ZIL

2010-03-06 Thread Edward Ned Harvey
> From everything I've seen, an SSD wins simply because it's 20-100x the > size. HBAs almost never have more than 512MB of cache, and even fancy > SAN boxes generally have 1-2GB max. So, HBAs are subject to being > overwhelmed with heavy I/O. The SSD ZIL has a much better chance of > being able to

Re: [osol-discuss] WriteBack versus SSD-ZIL

2010-03-05 Thread valrh...@gmail.com
According to Sun, you want to make sure you use an SLC SSD for a ZIL, which are a bit more expensive than the more-common MLC drives. There's the Intel X25-E, and then the OCZ Agility EX and OCZ Vertex EX. Those are about the only ones I know that have any significant presence in the market---bu

Re: [osol-discuss] WriteBack versus SSD-ZIL

2010-03-05 Thread Shawn Walker
On 03/ 5/10 11:20 AM, Travis Tabbal wrote: cache, as well, according to the HBA setup. And, a good (SLC) SSD can handle 50,000 IOPS until it's filled. Which takes a Are there any SSDs that are worth while that don't cost a ton? At the current prices for devices like the X25-E, even even those

Re: [osol-discuss] WriteBack versus SSD-ZIL

2010-03-05 Thread Travis Tabbal
> cache, as well, according to the HBA setup. And, a > good (SLC) SSD can > handle 50,000 IOPS until it's filled. Which takes a Are there any SSDs that are worth while that don't cost a ton? At the current prices for devices like the X25-E, even even those aren't perfect, I just can't justify

Re: [osol-discuss] WriteBack versus SSD-ZIL

2010-03-05 Thread Erik Trimble
Edward Ned Harvey wrote: In this email, when I say PERC, I really mean either a PERC, or any other hardware WriteBack buffered raid controller with BBU. For future server purchases, I want to know which is faster: (a) A bunch of hard disks with PERC and WriteBack enabled, or (b) A bunch of

[osol-discuss] WriteBack versus SSD-ZIL

2010-03-05 Thread Edward Ned Harvey
In this email, when I say PERC, I really mean either a PERC, or any other hardware WriteBack buffered raid controller with BBU. For future server purchases, I want to know which is faster: (a) A bunch of hard disks with PERC and WriteBack enabled, or (b) A bunch of hard disks, plus one SSD for