Re: [Openstack] [swift] RAID Performance Issue

2012-12-20 Thread Andrew Holway
---Chuck Thier > > > Chuck Thier > Sent by: openstack-bounces+zhuadl=cn.ibm@lists.launchpad.net > 2012-12-20 上午 12:33 > > > To > > David Busby , > > cc > > "openstack@lists.launchpad.net" > > Subject > > Re: [Openstack] [sw

Re: [Openstack] [swift] RAID Performance Issue

2012-12-20 Thread Chuck Thier
tack-bounces+zhuadl=cn.ibm@lists.launchpad.net > >2012-12-20 上午 12:33 > > > To > > >David Busby , > > > cc > > >"openstack@lists.launchpad.net" > > > Subject > > >Re: [Openstack] [swift] RAID Performance Issu

Re: [Openstack] [swift] RAID Performance Issue

2012-12-19 Thread Hua ZZ Zhang
m@lists.launchpad .net Subject Re: [Openstack] [swift] RAID Performance Issue

Re: [Openstack] [swift] RAID Performance Issue

2012-12-19 Thread Chuck Thier
There are a couple of things to think about when using RAID (or more specifically parity RAID) with swift. The first has already been identified in that the workload for swift is very write heavy with small random IO, which is very bad for most parity RAID. In our testing, under heavy workloads,

Re: [Openstack] [swift] RAID Performance Issue

2012-12-19 Thread David Busby
Hi Zang, As JuanFra points out there's not much sense in using Swift on top of raid as swift handel; extending on this RAID introduces a "write penalty" ( http://theithollow.com/2012/03/21/understanding-raid-penalty/) this in turn leads to performance issues, refer the link for write penalty's per

Re: [Openstack] [swift] RAID Performance Issue

2012-12-19 Thread JuanFra Rodriguez Cardoso
Hi Zang: Basically, it makes no sense to use Swift on top of RAID because Swift just delivers replication schema. Regards, JuanFra. 2012/12/19 Hua ZZ Zhang > Hi, > > I have read the admin document of Swift and find there's recommendation of > not using RAID 5 or 6 because swift performance deg

[Openstack] [swift] RAID Performance Issue

2012-12-19 Thread Hua ZZ Zhang
Hi, I have read the admin document of Swift and find there's recommendation of not using RAID 5 or 6 because swift performance degrades quickly with it. Can anyone explain why this could happen? If the RAID is done by hardware RAID controller, will the performance issue still exist? Anyone can sh