Re: [Openstack-operators] KVM memory overcommit with fast swap

2015-07-03 Thread George Shuklin
One notice: Even on the super-super-fast SSD, there is a huge overhead on IO. Basically, you can't go lower than 50 us on IO, and this is 5 ns, almost eternity for the modern processors. And you get minor page fault, which is not the fastest thing in the world. Few context switching,

Re: [Openstack-operators] KVM memory overcommit with fast swap

2015-07-03 Thread Blair Bethwaite
Damnit! So no-one has done this or has a feel for it? I was really hoping for the lazy option here. So next question. Ideas for convoluting a reasonable test case? Assuming I've got a compute node with 256GB RAM and 350GB of PCIe SSD for swap, what next? We've got Rally going so could potentially

[Openstack-operators] KVM memory overcommit with fast swap

2015-06-29 Thread Blair Bethwaite
Hi all, Question up-front: Do the performance characteristics of modern PCIe attached SSDs invalidate/challenge the old don't overcommit memory with KVM wisdom (recently discussed on this list and at meetups and summits)? Has anyone out there tried tested this? Long-form: I'm currently

Re: [Openstack-operators] KVM memory overcommit with fast swap

2015-06-29 Thread Warren Wang
I'm gonna forward this to my co-workers :) I've been kicking this idea around for some time now, and it hasn't caught traction. I think it could work for a modest overcommit, depending on the memory workload. We decided that it should be possible to do this sanely, but that it needed testing. I'm