Re: [opensuse] Re: MTBF was: Re: About Backing Up

2007-02-26 Thread James Knott
David Brodbeck wrote: > John Andersen wrote: > >> Bad analogy. You don't get a new life from an insurance policy. >> You do get a new drive from a warranty. >> >> > > Actually, you don't get a new drive. You get someone else's broken > drive that's been "factory refurbished." At least

Re: [opensuse] Re: MTBF was: Re: About Backing Up

2007-02-25 Thread David Brodbeck
John Andersen wrote: > > Bad analogy. You don't get a new life from an insurance policy. > You do get a new drive from a warranty. > Actually, you don't get a new drive. You get someone else's broken drive that's been "factory refurbished." At least from every manufacturer I've ever dealt wi

Re: [opensuse] Re: MTBF was: Re: About Backing Up

2007-02-24 Thread jdd
James Knott wrote: Although you can purchase insurance type warranties, you can't really compare life insurance with a product warranty. We all know that most of us will die eventually most HDrive will die :-(, the only question is when? same for us. for any manufacturer any _long_ term wara

Re: [opensuse] Re: MTBF was: Re: About Backing Up

2007-02-24 Thread John Andersen
On Saturday 24 February 2007, jdd wrote: > >  So, longer warranties simply mean that > > most drives will last to the end of the longer warranty period. > > of course not. Having a life insurance don't mean you will live longer... Bad analogy. You don't get a new life from an insurance policy. Yo

Re: [opensuse] Re: MTBF was: Re: About Backing Up

2007-02-24 Thread James Knott
jdd wrote: > James Knott wrote: > >> Warranties give the manufacturer an incentive to make drives that will >> outlast the warranty period. > > of course > >> So, longer warranties simply mean that >> most drives will last to the end of the longer warranty period. > > of course not. Having a life

Re: [opensuse] Re: MTBF was: Re: About Backing Up

2007-02-24 Thread jdd
James Knott wrote: Warranties give the manufacturer an incentive to make drives that will outlast the warranty period. of course So, longer warranties simply mean that most drives will last to the end of the longer warranty period. of course not. Having a life insurance don't mean you wil

Re: [opensuse] Re: MTBF was: Re: About Backing Up

2007-02-24 Thread James Knott
Eberhard Roloff wrote: > John Andersen wrote: > > >> Seagate offers 5 year warranties on sata these days. >> When it comes to buying drives, given two offerings with close-enough specs, >> I always go for the longer warranty. Any minor saving in price today will >> be lost when the drive fails

[opensuse] Re: MTBF was: Re: About Backing Up

2007-02-24 Thread Eberhard Roloff
John Andersen wrote: > On Friday 23 February 2007, Eberhard Roloff wrote: >> John Andersen wrote: >>> Seagate offers 5 year warranties on sata these days. >>> When it comes to buying drives, given two offerings with close-enough >>> specs, I always go for the longer warranty. Any minor saving in p

Re: [opensuse] Re: MTBF was: Re: About Backing Up

2007-02-24 Thread John Andersen
On Friday 23 February 2007, Eberhard Roloff wrote: > John Andersen wrote: > > Seagate offers 5 year warranties on sata these days. > > When it comes to buying drives, given two offerings with close-enough > > specs, I always go for the longer warranty. Any minor saving in price > > today will be l

[opensuse] Re: MTBF was: Re: About Backing Up

2007-02-24 Thread Eberhard Roloff
John Andersen wrote: > Seagate offers 5 year warranties on sata these days. > When it comes to buying drives, given two offerings with close-enough specs, > I always go for the longer warranty. Any minor saving in price today will > be lost when the drive fails in three years instead of 5 or 8. >