Pre-install MiniUPnPd on OpenWrt by default

2022-01-25 Thread Sergey Ponomarev
Hi, Most routers support port forwarding via UPnP IDG or/and NAT-PMP/PCP. And many vendors use the MiniUPnPd http://miniupnp.free.fr This daemon is kind of standard de-facto. This is necessary for any p2p application but OpenWrt builds don't have it pre-installed and pre-configured. While it's not

Re: Pre-install MiniUPnPd on OpenWrt by default

2022-01-25 Thread Stijn Segers
Hi Sergey, Op dinsdag 25 januari 2022 om 15u27 schreef Sergey Ponomarev : Hi, Most routers support port forwarding via UPnP IDG or/and NAT-PMP/PCP. And many vendors use the MiniUPnPd http://miniupnp.free.fr This daemon is kind of standard de-facto. This is necessary for any p2p application but

Re: Pre-install MiniUPnPd on OpenWrt by default

2022-01-25 Thread Sergey Ponomarev
I totally understand your concern and having a strict policy by default it's really a good practice to follow. I thought about this and IMHO the main problem here is most of the time that's a question of trade off. For example I developed a web app and to test OAuth flow I manually made a forwardi

Re: Pre-install MiniUPnPd on OpenWrt by default

2022-01-30 Thread Stijn Tintel
On 29/01/2022 12:53, Sergey Ponomarev wrote: > As a follow up I asked in a dev chat: > > Hi, Is there any process of deciding what to include into > OpenWrt builds by default? I sent a letter to devlist "Pre-install > MiniUPnPd on OpenWrt by default" but it seems not int

Re: Re: Pre-install MiniUPnPd on OpenWrt by default

2022-01-29 Thread Sergey Ponomarev
As a follow up I asked in a dev chat: Hi, Is there any process of deciding what to include into OpenWrt builds by default? I sent a letter to devlist "Pre-install MiniUPnPd on OpenWrt by default" but it seems not interesting in the context of devlist which is used mostly for patches