RE: Opinion Needed

2004-03-19 Thread Jens Bladt
Hi Larry As a piece of art in it self, I would crop it to avoid the half subjects. It's quite nice. As a photograph showing the objects to whoever intersted in things like this, I'd choose a different lighting, to avoid the dominating shadows. All the best Jens Bladt mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: Opinion Needed

2004-03-17 Thread Keith Whaley
Oh good! It wasn't just my monitor! Now I can agree with Alan. The dark background also varies in tone or lightness from the lighter bottom left (if I recall correctly) to top right, which is darker. It appears that was because it was (a guess) side lighted from a window or ?. keith whaley

Re: Opinion Needed

2004-03-17 Thread Paul Stenquist
I like the composition, framing and subject matter. But I don't like the light. It's most intense in the lower left and falls off very steeply. I do like the fact that the light is very directional because it creates interesting shadows, but I wish it came more from above left and was more

Re: Opinion Needed

2004-03-17 Thread Christian
The subject matter would be very appealing in certain circles Pony play anyone? Seriously though, I don't like the lighting, but the composition is good. Like others have said, I'd like to see a better-lit color version. Christian - Original Message - From: Larry Hodgson [EMAIL

RE: Opinion Needed

2004-03-17 Thread frank theriault
Hi, Larry, I fall into the it's too dark camp. I don't find the composition bad, but OTOH, it doesn't do a great deal for me. As Paul (and maybe others) said, the light fall off is bothersome. As has already been said, I wonder if it might work better in colour with better (more consistant)

Re: Opinion Needed and other thoughts

2004-03-17 Thread Larry Hodgson
Thanks to all who have commented on my image of the horse bits. I was undecided about this image in the first place. You have confirmed my initial feeling. It's just so-so and that's OK. What it did was to get me to look at lighting and composistion and color. This is a good thing as Martha would

Re: Opinion Needed

2004-03-16 Thread Peter J. Alling
On my monitor, which I've attempted to calibrate to my printer, it's a bit dark. It makes an interesting pattern. Larry Hodgson wrote: I like this image, but I'm not sure it would appeal to others. What are your thoughts? http://tripodman.smugmug.com/gallery/65381/2/2906163/Large Larry from

Re: Opinion Needed

2004-03-16 Thread Dr E D F Williams
One thing this picture tells us is that some Cowboys were cruel to their horses. Some of those bits are really nasty. Why no colour? Don ___ Dr E D F Williams http://personal.inet.fi/cool/don.williams Author's Web Site and Photo Gallery See Extra Pages 'The Cement Company from HELL!'