Re: [PEIRCE-L] Re: Theory and Analysis of Semeiosis (was Destinate Interpretant and Predestinate Opinion)

2020-05-31 Thread Jon Alan Schmidt
Helmut, List: I apologize for the delay, but I wanted to finish replying to Robert's ten items before posting anything else. Hopefully those responses have already addressed at least some of your questions. HR: But does a sign really transmit such a huge subset? No, a sign token does not

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Re: Theory and Analysis of Semeiosis (was Destinate Interpretant and Predestinate Opinion)

2020-05-31 Thread Jon Alan Schmidt
Robert, List: This post responds to #8, #9, and #10 below, completing my attempt to provide "clarifications that would allow [you] to access [my] full concept of semiosis." RM: "and thus the immediate (communicational) interpretant is a determination of the commens" …finally a clarification on

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Theory and Analysis of Semeiosis (was Destinate Interpretant and Predestinate Opinion)

2020-05-31 Thread John F. Sowa
Jon, Peirce devoted his life to developing mathematical-logical methods for making all the sciences, including philosophy, as clear and precise as possible. JAS> This post ... consists mostly of Peirce's words, with a few of mine interspersed, but I hope that the arrangement enables it all to