Re: [PEIRCE-L] Modal EGs in Delta vs. Gamma

2024-03-17 Thread John F Sowa
Jon, List, Before I read your note below, I had just sent an off-list note to you and Gary R. to recommend that you make very important revisions to your article. It's a pity that you had sent the article to the publisher so long ago. It's probably too late to stop the publication and make

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Logical Content of Graphical Signs (was Higher-Order Logics)

2024-03-17 Thread Jerry LR Chandler
Jon, John: > On Mar 12, 2024, at 4:59 PM, Jon Alan Schmidt > wrote: > > Jerry, List: > > Your questions as posed are extremely general, and their answers depend > heavily on the particular context of interest. Human reasoning is as general or as specific as the situation warrants in the

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Modal EGs in Delta vs. Gamma

2024-03-17 Thread Jon Alan Schmidt
John, List: JFS: Since your article has just been accepted for publication, you probably still have time to make a few corrections. Actually, my paper was accepted for publication (after review and revision) six months ago, and I see no need to correct anything at this point anyway--I stand by

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Peirce's Letter to Risteen (was Higher-Order Logics)

2024-03-17 Thread Jerry LR Chandler
John: > On Mar 13, 2024, at 4:24 PM, Gary Richmond wrote: > > JFS: Once again, Peirce's logic is at the forefront of 21st C developments. While in one sense, I agree with your ascertain, but probably for different reasons. The question is, what aspects of “21st C developments” are you

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Modal EGs in Delta vs. Gamma

2024-03-17 Thread John F Sowa
Jon, List, Since your article has just been accepted for publication, you probably still have time to make a few corrections. Following are some suggestions. JAS: Indeed, given that Peirce already had a notation for metalanguage in his 1903 Gamma EGs--in fact, five years earlier--how could