Edwina, List
ET> Who will judge whether X-person's
reading or Y-person's reading
'represents its author's original
intent? Who has this capacity to
make such a judgment?
The author is the only person who has the right to state his or her
intent. Following is one of Peirce's clearest statemen
Hi John and List,
I agree with Edwina's questions and I endorse the general sense of your
argument. But I disagree with your statement: "This implies that every
statement of his [Peirce's] philosophy must be evaluated in terms of his
logic." My perspective is that the universal categories are
