Re: [peirce-l] community of inquiry

2011-11-01 Thread John Collier
At 07:13 AM 2011/11/02, Terry Bristol wrote: I think that it might be helpful to explore the meanings of: Community of inquiry and Community of interpretation I think that these are very close if not the same. The aim of inquiry in pragmatism is no longer knowledge in the mechanical sense ­ lo

Re: [peirce-l] community of inquiry

2011-11-01 Thread Terry Bristol
I think that it might be helpful to explore the meanings of: Community of inquiry and Community of interpretation I think that these are very close if not the same. The aim of inquiry in pragmatism is no longer knowledge in the mechanical sense – logic-mathematical, where there are no real qualit

Re: [peirce-l] "Community of Inquiry": maybe incorporated in Royce?

2011-11-01 Thread Jonathan DeVore
Brief review, but possibly of interest: http://www.deakin.edu.au/dro/eserv/DU:30003655/jacobs-modelsofscientific-2006.pdf "Models of scientific community: Charles Sanders Peirce to Thomas Kuhn" Quoting John Welch : Maybe we should look in Royce, in what he wrote after listening carefully t

Re: [peirce-l] "Community of Inquiry": maybe incorporated in Royce?

2011-11-01 Thread John Welch
Maybe we should look in Royce, in what he wrote after listening carefully to Peirce. Problems of Christianity and, maybe, in the exchange with Dewey…in the complete Dewey, a nasty misunderstanding from a philosophy congress, around 1912 or ’13. Royce’s reply is a footnote to Dewey’s attack.

[peirce-l] "Community of Inquiry"

2011-11-01 Thread Aaron Massecar
Hi Maughn, John, List, I tried to send this earlier today, but it didn't go through for some reason. I am trying it again... After a search through the collected papers and the Chronological Writings (I have electronic versions of both), I could not find those three words put together. Tha

[peirce-l] Fw: Peirce Society: 2011-12 Essay Contest: 2nd Call for Submissions

2011-11-01 Thread Benjamin Udell
Duly forwarded, from Robert Lane of the Charles S. Peirce Society http://www.peircesociety.org/. - Ben - Original Message - From: Robert Lane To: The Charles S. Peirce Society Sent: Tuesday, November 01, 2011 11:43 AM Subject: Peirce Society: 2011-12 Essay Contest: 2nd Call for Submis

Re: [peirce-l] community of inquiry

2011-11-01 Thread Benjamin Udell
John, Michael, list, I'd look harder, but right now I've a nasty cold. I've looked and don't find Peirce speaking in so many words of a community of inquiry, inquirers, research, researchers, investigation, or investigators. It's occurred to me that, given that Peirce (in the "Fixation of Beli

Re: [peirce-l] community of inquiry

2011-11-01 Thread John Quay
Thank you very much for sharing these Michael - they are very helpful. One thought that has been with me lately is that such references do not merely point to a "community of inquiry," but rather to a "community of practice" for which inquiry is indispensible, whether this community is limited to

[peirce-l] "Community of Inquiry"

2011-11-01 Thread Maughn Gregory
Some years ago our library subscribed to the "Past Masters" service, which allowed electronic searching through Peirce's entire Collected Papers. I conducted a proximity search of the terms "community" and "inquiry" within 1-10 words of each other, and found no matches.  I concluded that the phr

Re: [peirce-l] community of inquiry

2011-11-01 Thread Michael J. DeLaurentis
By no means based on an exhaustive search, John, here are three passages which spring to mind, though not using the very phrase "community of inquiry." (1) "On the Doctrine of Chances..." : passim, including the following -- "...three sentiments, namely, interest in an indefinite community, recogni

[peirce-l] community of inquiry

2011-11-01 Thread John Quay
Hi Peirce-listers Just wondering if anyone can help me. The phrase "community of inquiry" is often attributed to Peirce and yet I cannot find any instance of his actually using this phrase. Sources of this attribution can be drawn to Matthew Lipman (amongst others), associated with his work in Ph