[PEN-L:5616] Re: Rethinking Overdetemination

In reply to Shawgi Tell: I wouldn't use Stalin as much of an authority! Engels popularized much, and one must take into account the nature of political discourse, certainly not a philosophical authority. Marx and Engels have plenty to accommodate overdetermination. Overdetermination, by the way,

[PEN-L:5615] Re: Rethinking Overdetemination

I'm sorry Paul, I don't understand: what is "economic determinism?" Shawgi Tell University at Buffalo Graduate School of Education [EMAIL PROTECTED] On Sat, 10 Aug 1996, Paul Zarembka wrote: > Shawgi, > > Are you proposing economic determinism or what? What about Engels > comment that he a

[PEN-L:5614] Re: Rethinking Overdetemination

Shawgi, Are you proposing economic determinism or what? What about Engels comment that he and Marx are partly to blame for over-emphasizing the economic at the expense of other factors? Also, where do Marx and Engels take the position you are ascribing to them? (I don't care about Stalin's opin