Steve Keen, i guess inadvertently, sent this posting to me. I'm forwarding it
to the net since it appears to be intended for it. Ajit Sinha
Original message
A brief (supportive) comment on Ajit's posting re Sraffa. Since his
purpose was reall
In Message Tue, 01 Mar 1994 20:07:27 -0500 (EST),
[EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:
>Gil's response to Ajit, Part 2.
..
..
>This brings all, or at least most, of the pieces together. Ajit's
>argument here encounters a fundamental dilemma:
>
>EITHER
>1) CAPITAL cannot be considered the "bigger story" b
In Message Tue, 01 Mar 1994 20:07:27 -0500 (EST),
[EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:
>Gil's response to Ajit, Part 2.
..
..
>This brings all, or at least most, of the pieces together. Ajit's
>argument here encounters a fundamental dilemma:
>
>EITHER
>1) CAPITAL cannot be considered the "bigger story" b
Gil's response to Ajit, Part 2. My comments to follow are basically
tailored elaborations of my prologue, with a few interesting
exceptions--e.g., concerning Ajit's claim that the context underlying
the Sraffian system is supplied by Marx's _CAPITAL_. I suggest
reasons to doubt this. Commen
Gil's response to Ajit, Part 2. My comments to follow are basically
tailored elaborations of my prologue, with a few interesting
exceptions--e.g., concerning Ajit's claim that the context underlying
the Sraffian system is supplied by Marx's _CAPITAL_. I suggest
reasons to doubt this. Commen
When Ajit replies to my claim that the Sraffian model is just
equivalent to a GE system with a lot of stuff left out by saying
that in Sraffa-land (or what Ajit calls the "surplus approach"),
quote, "The real wage is determined by social and historical forces",
I say right, he's just listing s
When Ajit replies to my claim that the Sraffian model is just
equivalent to a GE system with a lot of stuff left out by saying
that in Sraffa-land (or what Ajit calls the "surplus approach"),
quote, "The real wage is determined by social and historical forces",
I say right, he's just listing s
To remind the reader, Gil Skillman earlier characterized the "Sraffian system
of commodity prices of production" as "just a GE system with a lot of stuff
left out..." In my earlier posting, I showed surprise at Gil's characterization
and reminded him that the three basic aspects of the GE model, n
To remind the reader, Gil Skillman earlier characterized the "Sraffian system
of commodity prices of production" as "just a GE system with a lot of stuff
left out..." In my earlier posting, I showed surprise at Gil's characterization
and reminded him that the three basic aspects of the GE model, n
