Re: Re: Hutton's declaration of war 2

2002-05-22 Thread Rob Schaap
> But of course Chris did not write the words attributed to him, as the > thread title and his preamble showed. > > The failure to show respect to the opposing argument and actually deal > with it, >but to dismiss the individual with disrepect, is symptomatic > of this approach to >marxism.

Re: Hutton's declaration of war 2

2002-05-22 Thread Chris Burford
At 20/05/02 18:01 -0700, Jim Devine quoted Louis Proyect >On Mon, 20 May 2002 22:32:27 +0100, Chris Burford wrote: > >If once the United States personified the > >future, increasingly the EU is demonstrating how > > inter-dependence can be managed and nurtured. > >LP: This must be some kind of jo

RE: Re: Hutton's declaration of war 2

2002-05-20 Thread Devine, James
On Mon, 20 May 2002 22:32:27 +0100, Chris Burford wrote: >If once the United States personified the >future, increasingly the EU is demonstrating how > inter-dependence can be managed and nurtured. LP: This must be some kind of joke. Anti-immigrant violence is spreading across Europe while the "

Re: Hutton's declaration of war 2

2002-05-20 Thread Louis Proyect
On Mon, 20 May 2002 22:32:27 +0100, Chris Burford wrote: >If once the United States personified the >future, increasingly the EU is demonstrating how > inter-dependence can be managed and nurtured. This must be some kind of joke. Anti-immigrant violence is spreading across Europe while the "thir

Hutton's declaration of war 2

2002-05-20 Thread Chris Burford
Of course Hutton's purpose is not emphasis that Europe too is an imperialism and no less genetically capable of committing atrocities of oppression and exploitation than its rival across the Atlantic. But in the following passage Hutton continues by arguing why Europe has the more effective approa