kashmir and india (was Re: India's HDI Improves, Ranking Doesn't)

2004-07-29 Thread ravi
Chris Doss wrote: --- ravi [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: nothing unites like hate. and for that there is pakistan and/or muslims. the common language i share with my indian spouse is english. but not to worry with respect to commonality... advice from some relatives/acquaintances on both sides

Re: India's HDI Improves, Ranking Doesn't

2004-07-28 Thread Chris Doss
--- ravi [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: nothing unites like hate. and for that there is pakistan and/or muslims. the common language i share with my indian spouse is english. but not to worry with respect to commonality... advice from some relatives/acquaintances on both sides struck a common chord:

Re: India's HDI Improves, Ranking Doesn't

2004-07-27 Thread ravi
Anthony D'Costa wrote: There are two main national languages: Hindi and English. A good number of people don't speak either. But they tend to be from rural areas from the non-Hindi belt. my experience differs somewhat from this assessment. i am from madras which is definitely from the

Re: India's HDI Improves, Ranking Doesn't

2004-07-27 Thread ravi
Chris Doss wrote: Given that knowledge of English is so low and the absence of a national language (I guess), what is the lingua franca in India? I mean, is there any language that people anywhere in India would be able to communicate in (like Russian in the fSU)? Without that, I imagine it

Re: India's HDI Improves, Ranking Doesn't

2004-07-26 Thread Anthony D'Costa
There are two main national languages: Hindi and English. A good number of people don't speak either. But they tend to be from rural areas from the non-Hindi belt. But Hindi is spoken by more people than English and would easily run into several hundred millions. Even 4% of Indians speaking

Re: India's HDI Improves, Ranking Doesn't

2004-07-24 Thread Chris Doss
--- Anthony D'Costa [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: This is hard to estimate but the numbers that float around, are 3-4% of the population, which is not a small number by any means. English has been both a uniting factor (in a national sense) but also one that sets the rural-urban and class divide more

Re: India's HDI Improves, Ranking Doesn't

2004-07-22 Thread Doug Henwood
Anthony D'Costa wrote: There are other splits, which have been better handled, for example language. Thus far 20 languages or so have been recognized by the government. How widely used is English? Doug

Re: India's HDI Improves, Ranking Doesn't

2004-07-22 Thread Ulhas Joglekar
Anthony D'Costa wrote: The Hindu-Muslim divide is India's least problematic cultural divide. Hindu-Muslim divide has the potential to threaten India's unity and democratic structure. Caste divide does not have that potential. The Indian government has generally handled demands for autonomy

Re: India's HDI Improves, Ranking Doesn't

2004-07-22 Thread Anthony D'Costa
This is hard to estimate but the numbers that float around, are 3-4% of the population, which is not a small number by any means. English has been both a uniting factor (in a national sense) but also one that sets the rural-urban and class divide more forcefully. Indians want their children to

India's HDI Improves, Ranking Doesn't

2004-07-21 Thread Ulhas Joglekar
The Financial ExpressFriday, July 16, 2004HDI Improves, Ranking Doesn'tOUR POLICY BUREAUPosted online: Friday, July 16, 2004 at 0103 hours ISTNEW DELHI, JULY 15: India's human development index (HDI) has shown asteady improvement in the last couple of years. India's ranking, however, at127 out of

Re: India's HDI Improves, Ranking Doesn't

2004-07-21 Thread Michael Perelman
To what extent has India managed to handle it diversity other than the Hindu/Muslim split? -- Michael Perelman Economics Department California State University Chico, CA 95929 Tel. 530-898-5321 E-Mail michael at ecst.csuchico.edu

India's HDI Improves, Ranking Doesn't

2004-07-21 Thread Ulhas Joglekar
The Financial ExpressFriday, July 16, 2004HDI Improves, Ranking Doesn'tOUR POLICY BUREAUPosted online: Friday, July 16, 2004 at 0103 hours ISTNEW DELHI, JULY 15: India's human development index (HDI) has shown asteady improvement in the last couple of years. India's ranking, however, at127 out of

Re: India's HDI Improves, Ranking Doesn't

2004-07-21 Thread Anthony D'Costa
This requires a long response but I must make it short. The Hindu-Muslim divide is India's least problematic cultural divide. If one were to rank the splits (which in itself is problematic because of its binary approach) it would the dalits and the tribal communities versus the rest. The dalits