RE: George Monbiot and David Harvey

2003-02-18 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:34837] George Monbiot and David Harvey this is an interesting article, but as Monbiot portrays it, Harvey's analysis is too mechanical and too pat. The idea seems to be that a structural specific economic problem (under-use of industrial capacity) provokes the ruling class

Re: Re: George Monbiot and David Harvey

2003-02-18 Thread soula avramidis
I thought it simply demystifies an expansionist process and pinpoints the real enemy as capital, that being a detrimental social relationship tying up all, and allĀ emerging events in the present epoch of history. It sort of makes the life process of humanity one and the same and bridges differenc

Re: George Monbiot and David Harvey

2003-02-18 Thread Chris Burford
Not only are these analyses serious in their own right. They mark a new deepening in the democratic opposition to the present executors of the will of finance capital, at the same time as the popular movement widens in its extent and its contact with whole populations. The role of capital is no