RE: Re: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: JD on EITC (Was Krugman Watch)

2000-05-29 Thread Max Sawicky
Jim Devine wrote: > Oh goody! I've always admired magazines like COSMO with their constant > barrage of quizzes ("Are You Giving Your Man All that He Wants?"). Luckily, MBS has provided us with a "Are You a Left-Wing-Left-Wing Communist?" quiz. CC: Since I would need sliga wire to separate Jim's

Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: JD on EITC (Was Krugman Watch)

2000-05-29 Thread Doyle Saylor
Greetings Economists, Interesting exchange between Carrol, and MBS about Eitc, and the RAL as MBS puts those things. Max Sawicky writes, All these questions become a kind of political dynamite when the next recession comes along -- when the myth that welfare is the cause of unemployment is

Re: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: JD on EITC (Was Krugman Watch)

2000-05-29 Thread Carrol Cox
Jim Devine wrote: > Oh goody! I've always admired magazines like COSMO with their constant > barrage of quizzes ("Are You Giving Your Man All that He Wants?"). Luckily, > MBS has provided us with a "Are You a Left-Wing-Left-Wing Communist?" quiz. Since I would need sliga wire to separate Jim'

Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: JD on EITC (Was Krugman Watch)

2000-05-29 Thread Jim Devine
Oh goody! I've always admired magazines like COSMO with their constant barrage of quizzes ("Are You Giving Your Man All that He Wants?"). Luckily, MBS has provided us with a "Are You a Left-Wing-Left-Wing Communist?" quiz. >Some of these [characteristics of left-wing-left-wing communism] would

Re: Re: RE: Re: JD on EITC (Was Krugman Watch)

2000-05-29 Thread J. Barkley Rosser, Jr.
thing published. I still have it around somewhere. :-). Barkley Rosser -Original Message- From: Jim Devine <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Date: Monday, May 29, 2000 3:43 PM Subject: [PEN-L:19729] Re: RE: Re: JD on EITC (Was Krugman Watch)

RE: Re: RE: Re: JD on EITC (Was Krugman Watch)

2000-05-29 Thread Max Sawicky
Max Sawicky wrote: > It encourages ultimatism and > left-wing-left-wing communism. CC: One learns new isms all the time. Incidentally what is the difference between left-wing communism and left-wing-left-wing communism? [mbs] the same as the difference between overdone and burnt to a cinder. C

Re: RE: Re: JD on EITC (Was Krugman Watch)

2000-05-29 Thread Jim Devine
At 01:38 PM 05/29/2000 -0700, you wrote: >JD: . . . >(BTW, I can't believe that I awakened MBS's ire so much when I asserted >that "the earned income credit (unlike classic income-support measures) >make workers more dependent on their employers' good wishes, i.e., hardly >helps their bargainin

Re: Re: RE: Re: JD on EITC (Was Krugman Watch)

2000-05-29 Thread Joel Blau
Although the insistence on work for those on welfare blurs the line a bit, the working poor (EITC) continue to be treated better than those on welfare. TANF recipients are subjected to constant harassment to demonstrate their need; EITC have tax forms to fill out, but face no comparable harassme

Re: RE: Re: JD on EITC (Was Krugman Watch)

2000-05-29 Thread Carrol Cox
Max Sawicky wrote: > It encourages ultimatism and > left-wing-left-wing communism. One learns new isms all the time. Incidentally what is the difference between left-wing communism and left-wing-left-wing communism? The usual defining feature of ultra-leftism is a refusal to work with "bourg

RE: Re: JD on EITC (Was Krugman Watch)

2000-05-29 Thread Max Sawicky
JD: . . . (BTW, I can't believe that I awakened MBS's ire so much when I asserted that "the earned income credit (unlike classic income-support measures) make workers more dependent on their employers' good wishes, i.e., hardly helps their bargaining power." This is hardly a radical statement.)