Re: Re: Re: Engels, Marx, Value and Communism

2002-02-04 Thread miyachi
on 2/5/02 00:42 AM, [EMAIL PROTECTED] at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > It is not that Engels misunderstood Marx. Marx unfolded a new law system. > Engels agreed to the best of his ability. To continue. > >> MIYACHI TATSUO >> PSYCHIATRIC DEPARTMENT >> KOMAKI MUNICIPAL HOSPITAL >> KOMAKI CITY >> AICHI

Re: Re: Engels, Marx, Value and Communism

2002-02-04 Thread Waistline2
It is not that Engels misunderstood Marx. Marx unfolded a new law system. Engels agreed to the best of his ability. To continue. >MIYACHI TATSUO >PSYCHIATRIC DEPARTMENT >KOMAKI MUNICIPAL HOSPITAL >KOMAKI CITY >AICHI Pre. >JAPAN [EMAIL PROTECTED] >>Below is from "Capital" >>"The specific eco

Re: Re: Engels, Marx, Value and Communism

2002-02-04 Thread Waistline2
>Engels misunderstood Marx's value theory, especially Marx's explanation of >money-form of commodity as" physically accountable entity, but Marx >explains " social, homogenous labor" firstly as imaginary or ideal product. >Below is borrowed from "Capital I do not disagee that there existed a dif

Re: Engels, Marx, Value and Communism

2002-02-02 Thread miyachi
on 2/2/02 08:34 PM, [EMAIL PROTECTED] at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > I happen to be one who believes that there exists a difference in > articulation - not substance, between Frederick Engels and Karl Marx approach > to "value" and embrace the reshaping of the "theory of value" in the hands of > M