Re: RE: Re: military strategy

2002-09-17 Thread Carrol Cox
Devine, James wrote: Do you think that the US North's defense of the Union against the South was really against slave society? It had the effect of destroying that society (or at least of converting slaves into debt peons), but the war was about defense of the union, disputes about

Re: Re: RE: Re: military strategy

2002-09-17 Thread Michael Perelman
Carrol seems to have correctly distinguised between a war against a slave society and a war against slavery. The North believed that it could not compete effectively within a slave society, which depended upon low tariffs and unfree labor. I found the passage that I posted interesting because