RE: Re: RE: thanks for the zillion references to Marx? (plea se check the list)

2000-11-30 Thread Mikalac Norman S NSSC
thanks, justin, for culling the junk out of this list. norm -Original Message- From: Justin Schwartz [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2000 4:15 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [PEN-L:5121] Re: RE: thanks for the zillion references to Marx? (plea se check

RE: Re: Re: RE: thanks for the zillion references to Marx? (plea se check the list)

2000-11-30 Thread Mikalac Norman S NSSC
ok, ths, louis. Novack goes back onto the list. norm -Original Message- From: Louis Proyect [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2000 4:23 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [PEN-L:5123] Re: Re: RE: thanks for the zillion references to Marx? (plea se check the list

RE: Re: Re: Re: RE: thanks for the zillion references to Marx?(plea se check the list)

2000-11-30 Thread Mikalac Norman S NSSC
] Subject: [PEN-L:5131] Re: Re: Re: RE: thanks for the zillion references to Marx?(plea se check the list) Preliminary: You aren't reading Marxism seriously unless you read Amilcar Cabral and the major works of Mao. To see Marxism in gritty practice, see the greatest U.S. book of the 20th century

Re: Re: RE: thanks for the zillion references to Marx? (plea se check the list)

2000-11-29 Thread Louis Proyect
Justin: Introduction to the Logic of Marxism - George Novack Dull and antiquated. George was a friend of mine. Whatever he lacks in stylistic panache, he more than makes up for in thoroughness and ease of understanding. As far as the complaint of being "antiquated" is concerned, I suppose this

Re: Re: Re: RE: thanks for the zillion references to Marx?(plea se check the list)

2000-11-29 Thread Carrol Cox
Preliminary: You aren't reading Marxism seriously unless you read Amilcar Cabral and the major works of Mao. To see Marxism in gritty practice, see the greatest U.S. book of the 20th century, Hinton, *Fanshen.* Ellen Meiksins Wood, *The Retreat from Class: A New "True" Socialism*