Re: Re: Re: Re: Leftist (but non-Marxist) economists wanted in Europe

2000-11-12 Thread Joel Blau
Max: The wealth tax is a real difference. Enacting the Ackerman/Alstott scheme might better than anything else now on the horizon. But stake or no stake, I am still wary of the notion of each individual poor person as atomized consumer/investor. It may be an accurate reflection of our social

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Leftist (but non-Marxist) economists wanted in Europe

2000-11-12 Thread Max Sawicky
I agree that's well taken. But insofar as a great part of our consumption is individually financed, and ever more will be so, redistributing wealth in the form of cash will be an enduring and compelling option in the pursuit of equality. mbs The wealth tax is a real difference. Enacting the

Re: Re: Re: Leftist (but non-Marxist) economists wanted in Europe

2000-11-11 Thread Max Sawicky
response to Joel B: The Ackerman/Alstott scheme is different from IDA's in some key respects. Typically with IDA's the account holder contributes in some measure, so it would be hard to have an IDA at age 21 based on contributions from earnings prior to that age. Ackerman/Alstott propose a