Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Max Weber's Genteel Racism (was Re: weber)

2000-12-10 Thread Louis Proyect
Anthony D'Costa: But Korea didn't get an infusion of capital as in FDI. The United States financed almost 70 percent of South Korea's imports between 1953 and 1962. Louis Proyect Marxism mailing list: http://www.marxmail.org/

Re: Re: Re: Re: Max Weber's Genteel Racism (was Re: weber)

2000-12-09 Thread Louis Proyect
Anthony D'Costa Is this development by invitation a la Wallerstein? Dependent development or that imperialism does not necessarily mean pillage as you underscored earlier. Right. In a few exceptional cases, third world countries benefited from an infusion of capital because of their strategic

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Max Weber's Genteel Racism (was Re: weber)

2000-12-09 Thread Anthony D'Costa
On Sat, 9 Dec 2000, Louis Proyect wrote: Anthony D'Costa Is this development by invitation a la Wallerstein? Dependent development or that imperialism does not necessarily mean pillage as you underscored earlier. Right. In a few exceptional cases, third world countries benefited from an

Re: Re: Re: Re: Max Weber's Genteel Racism (was Re: weber)

2000-12-08 Thread Louis Proyect
Anthony D;Costa wrote: Korea took off because it was colonized (Japan/US). No, it was because of its role as a garrison state of US imperialism and because of the protectionist manufacturing policies. Louis Proyect Marxism mailing list: http://www.marxmail.org

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Max Weber's Genteel Racism (was Re: weber)

2000-12-08 Thread Doug Henwood
Louis Proyect wrote: Anthony D;Costa wrote: Korea took off because it was colonized (Japan/US). No, it was because of its role as a garrison state of US imperialism and because of the protectionist manufacturing policies. How is "garrison state" different from "colonized," and how did a

Re: Re: Re: Re: Max Weber's Genteel Racism (was Re: weber)

2000-12-07 Thread Louis Proyect
Spain also became colonialist and didn't "take off." Ditto Portugal. Silver and gold ran out. Slaves + earth + water + cotton seeds or sugar seeds lasts forever. The Netherlands sank and Britain rose, though both were colonial powers. Germany was only a middling imperial power but became an

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Max Weber's Genteel Racism (was Re: weber)

2000-12-07 Thread Doug Henwood
Louis Proyect wrote: The question was whether enclosures lead to a "take off". Sounds to me like you have some other question on your mind, but I am no mind reader. Something internally happened in Britain. Colonialism was a necessary but not sufficient condition for takeoff. Or am I missing

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Max Weber's Genteel Racism (was Re: weber)

2000-12-07 Thread Louis Proyect
Louis Proyect wrote: The question was whether enclosures lead to a "take off". Sounds to me like you have some other question on your mind, but I am no mind reader. Something internally happened in Britain. Colonialism was a necessary but not sufficient condition for takeoff. Or am I missing

Re: Re: Re: Re: Max Weber's Genteel Racism (was Re: weber)

2000-12-07 Thread Louis Proyect
You should also check the very latest scholarship on Spain in this period, edited by I.A.A. Thompson and Bartolomé Yun Casalilla and titled "The Castilian Crisis of the Seventeenth Century." what does it say? I covered it in my longish post on B-r a couple of weeks ago. You can find it in