Re: Re: rev and reform

2002-01-25 Thread Michael Perelman
please take it off list. Thanks. On Fri, Jan 25, 2002 at 03:48:01PM -0800, Rakesh Bhandari wrote: > > > > > > > >CB: You do accept that "dictatorship of the proletariat" is Marx's > >formulation though, right ? So, what is the Luxemburg, Mattick , > >Draper, Thomas formulation of the

Re: rev and reform

2002-01-25 Thread Rakesh Bhandari
> > > >CB: You do accept that "dictatorship of the proletariat" is Marx's >formulation though, right ? So, what is the Luxemburg, Mattick , >Draper, Thomas formulation of the dicatatorship of the proletariat ? It's not the Bolshevik one, don't you know. > > > >CB: You can't d

Re: rev and reform

2002-01-25 Thread Rakesh Bhandari
> >CB: Yes, actually, I was going to type in some of Perlo's chapter >>"The Rate of Profit". The funny thing is Perlo uses both the famous >>"anti-consumptionist" quote from Vol. II that you stand on and the >>"ultimate cosuming power of society" quote from Vol. III that shows >>your view is onl