Re: The concept of corruption

2003-11-03 Thread Devine, James
I don't feel the need to be a dictionary every time discussion of terms comes up. ... no, you don't have to provide definitions all the time. But if you reject some definition of some word (e.g., corruption) it seems that you have some alternative definition in mind, which you should share

Re: The concept of corruption

2003-11-03 Thread Michael Perelman
I have no idea how to define corruption. Corporate campaign contributions seem corrupt to me, but not according to American standards. Appointing right-wing hacks to the courts and other political positions since corrupt. Giving away a public resources seem corrupt. Clinton using his power of

Re: The concept of corruption

2003-11-03 Thread andie nachgeborenen
Judge John T. Noonan has a big and interesting book on the history of corruption, Bribery (1984), really a fascinating read. Standards definitely evolve. In the early common law, it was normal for judges to take gifts from litigants. By the time of Francis Bacon, impeached for corruption from the

Re: The concept of corruption

2003-11-03 Thread Jurriaan Bendien
In short, a concept like this defies definition. I don't think that's true, Marx would say, definitions of corruption are historically relative. But in the foundations of bourgeois society and moral thinking, corruption just means unfair competition, and this is normally legally defined. But

Re: The concept of corruption

2003-11-03 Thread Devine, James
] The concept of corruption In short, a concept like this defies definition. I don't think that's true, Marx would say, definitions of corruption are historically relative. But in the foundations of bourgeois society and moral thinking, corruption just means unfair competition

The concept of corruption

2003-11-02 Thread Jurriaan Bendien
Corruption is defined as the abuse of public power for private gain. Alexander Sack, the author and legal scholar of the doctrine of odious debts, included in his definition of odious debts, loans incurred by members of the government or by persons or groups associated with the government to serve

Re: The concept of corruption

2003-11-02 Thread Eubulides
- Original Message - From: Jurriaan Bendien [EMAIL PROTECTED] Corruption is defined as the abuse of public power for private gain. === This is way too thin a definition of corruption. It concedes too much to methodological individualism. Ian Alexander Sack,

Re: The concept of corruption

2003-11-02 Thread joanna bujes
Corruption is defined as the abuse of public power for private gain. === This is way too thin a definition of corruption. It concedes too much to methodological individualism. Ian The definition seems pretty good to me. What's methodological individualism? Joanna

Re: The concept of corruption

2003-11-02 Thread Eubulides
- Original Message - From: joanna bujes [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Sunday, November 02, 2003 5:31 PM Subject: Re: [PEN-L] The concept of corruption Corruption is defined as the abuse of public power for private gain. snip The definition seems pretty good

Re: The concept of corruption

2003-11-02 Thread Devine, James
-Original Message- From: Eubulides [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Sun 11/2/2003 5:39 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: Subject: Re: [PEN-L] The concept of corruption Corruption is defined as the abuse

Re: The concept of corruption

2003-11-02 Thread andie nachgeborenen
Science (1993). jks --- Eubulides [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: - Original Message - From: joanna bujes [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Sunday, November 02, 2003 5:31 PM Subject: Re: [PEN-L] The concept of corruption Corruption is defined as the abuse of public

Re: The concept of corruption

2003-11-02 Thread joanna bujes
: Re: [PEN-L] The concept of corruption Corruption is defined as the abuse of public power for private gain. snip The definition seems pretty good to me. What's methodological individualism? Joanna == It makes all politics and commerce corrupt by definition

Re: The concept of corruption

2003-11-02 Thread Eubulides
- Original Message - From: Devine, James [EMAIL PROTECTED] If we don't take capitalist norms for granted, then the _whole system_ is corrupt in that it involves the state enforcement of capitalist exploitation (which benefits private interests). In that case, conventionally-defined