So far, except for a slight eruption of antagonism between Lou and Carrol, the debate has gone remarkably well so far in terms of avoiding personal attacks-even veiled attacks. I would not like to see this to generate too far. > Louis Proyect wrote: > > >These questions would have more punch if we weren't dealing with an > >widespread academic Menshevik milieu which views capitalism as being a step > >up in the evolutionary ladder. ..... If one can go flitting > >about to academic conferences on an expense account making speeches in awe > >of skyscrapers, jet planes and indoor plumbing using Marxish verbiage, then > >this is like having your cake and eating it too. > -- Michael Perelman Economics Department California State University Chico, CA 95929 Tel. 530-898-5321 E-Mail [EMAIL PROTECTED]
- Re: Re: Capitalism as slavery a... Jim Devine
- Query re Braudel, Re: Carrol Cox
- RE: Capitalism as slavery and colonialism Austin, Andrew
- Re: RE: Capitalism as slavery and colonialism Louis Proyect
- Re: Re: RE: Capitalism as slavery and colonialis... Jim Devine
- Re: Re: Re: RE: Capitalism as slavery and co... Louis Proyect
- RE: Re: Re: RE: Capitalism as slavery and co... Max Sawicky
- Re: Re: RE: Capitalism as slavery and colonialis... Doug Henwood
- Re: Re: Capitalism as slavery and colonialis... Louis Proyect
- Re: Capitalism as slavery and colonialis... Yoshie Furuhashi
- Re: Capitalism as slavery and colonialism Michael Perelman
- Re: Capitalism as slavery and colonialism Yoshie Furuhashi
- Re: Re: RE: Capitalism as slavery and colonialis... Ken Hanly
- RE: RE: Capitalism as slavery and colonialism Austin, Andrew
- Re: RE: RE: Capitalism as slavery and colonialism Louis Proyect
- Re: Capitalism as slavery and colonialism Yoshie Furuhashi
- Re: Re: Capitalism as slavery and colonialis... Louis Proyect
- Re: Capitalism as slavery and colonialis... Yoshie Furuhashi
- Re: Re: Capitalism as slavery and c... Louis Proyect
- Re: Re: Re: Capitalism as slave... Jim Devine
- Re: Re: Re: Re: Capitalism as s... Louis Proyect