[PEN-L] Internal Relations [was tobin's q oil}

2005-07-06 Thread Charles Brown
From: Ted Winslow Here is another elaboration of the idea of social relations as internal relations from the German Ideology. ^ CB: I was starting to think that internal relations _are_ social relations, as when you say: Relations are internal where the essence of the individual is the

Re: [PEN-L] Internal Relations [was tobin's q oil}

2005-07-06 Thread Autoplectic
On 7/6/05, Charles Brown [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: What is the intuitive in direct intuitive observation ? - Ah, but it's axiomatic to some that neither intuitive nor direct intuitive observation can be analyzed in terms of any thing more fundamental than themselves. As if

Re: [PEN-L] Internal Relations [was tobin's q oil}

2005-07-02 Thread Ted Winslow
Charles Brown wrote: CB: If I understand here, internal relations are anti-Robinsonade logic ,so to speak ? Relations are internal where the essence of the individual is the outcome of its relations. Robinsonades are those who implicitly treat the essence of the individual as